Cement Board Subfloor Instead of Plywood? (1 Pro Knows!)
Think about it: kids spend a lot of time on the floor, playing, crawling, and, let’s be honest, sometimes falling. The right flooring can make a huge difference in their well-being.
We’re talking about preventing slips, avoiding nasty allergens, and making sure the materials we use are safe for little ones.
Now, when it comes to subflooring, the unsung hero beneath your beautiful floors, plywood has been the go-to for ages. But is it always the best choice, especially with kids in the picture?
That’s where cement board comes in. You might know it from bathroom renovations, but it’s gaining popularity as a subfloor alternative, and for good reason.
In this article, I’m going to break down why cement board might be a better choice than plywood for families. I’ll share my insights, based on years of experience, so you can make the best decision for your home and your kids. Let’s get started!
Section 1: The Role of Flooring in Child Safety
Flooring isn’t just a surface; it’s a foundation for your child’s safety and health. Let’s dive into how it really impacts your little ones.
Slip Resistance: Preventing Those Tumbles
Kids are like little explorers, always on the move. That means slips and falls are practically inevitable. The type of flooring you choose can significantly reduce the risk of accidents.
Think about it: a slick tile floor versus a textured vinyl. Which one sounds safer for a toddler learning to walk? According to the National Safety Council, falls are a leading cause of injury for children.
Choosing flooring with good slip resistance is a simple way to create a safer environment. Look for materials with a high static coefficient of friction (SCOF). Generally, a SCOF of 0.5 or higher is recommended for level surfaces.
Durability: Standing Up to Kid-Level Wear and Tear
Kids are tough on floors. Spills, dropped toys, and endless foot traffic can take their toll. Durable flooring can withstand the daily onslaught and maintain its integrity.
I’ve seen floors ruined by a single dropped sippy cup or a rogue crayon. Opting for durable materials like cement board can save you from costly repairs and replacements down the road. Plus, it keeps your home looking its best, even with a whirlwind of activity.
Allergens and Toxins: Creating a Healthy Environment
Did you know that some flooring materials can release harmful chemicals and trap allergens? Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) are emitted from some adhesives and finishes, which can affect indoor air quality.
Children are more vulnerable to these toxins because their bodies are still developing. Choosing low-VOC or VOC-free flooring options is crucial for protecting their health. Cement board is naturally inert and doesn’t off-gas, making it a safer choice for families.
According to the EPA, indoor air pollutants can be 2 to 5 times higher than outdoor levels. So, paying attention to the materials you bring into your home can make a big difference in your family’s well-being.
Section 2: Understanding Plywood as a Subfloor Material
Plywood has been a staple in construction for decades, and for good reason. But let’s take a closer look at what it is and its pros and cons.
What is Plywood?
Plywood is an engineered wood product made by gluing together multiple layers of wood veneer. These layers, called plies, are arranged with their grain running in alternating directions. This cross-graining gives plywood its strength and stability.
There are different types of plywood, each with its own characteristics. Common types include:
-
Softwood Plywood: Typically made from pine, fir, or spruce. It’s often used for general construction and sheathing.
-
Hardwood Plywood: Made from woods like birch, maple, or oak. It’s often used for furniture, cabinets, and decorative applications.
-
Exterior Plywood: Designed to withstand moisture and exposure to the elements. It’s used for siding, roofing, and other outdoor applications.
Advantages of Plywood
-
Affordability: Plywood is generally more affordable than other subfloor options, like cement board. This makes it an attractive choice for budget-conscious homeowners.
-
Availability: Plywood is readily available at most home improvement stores and lumberyards. You can easily find it in various thicknesses and sizes.
-
Ease of Installation: Plywood is relatively easy to cut, fasten, and install. Most contractors are familiar with working with plywood, which can save you time and money on labor costs.
Drawbacks of Plywood
-
Moisture Susceptibility: This is the big one. Plywood is highly susceptible to moisture damage. When exposed to water, it can warp, swell, and even rot. This can lead to structural problems and the growth of mold and mildew, which can be harmful to your family’s health.
-
Long-Term Durability: While plywood is strong, it’s not as durable as other subfloor options. Over time, it can sag, delaminate, and become unstable, especially in high-traffic areas.
-
VOC Emissions: Some plywood contains adhesives that release VOCs. These chemicals can contribute to poor indoor air quality and may cause respiratory problems, especially in children.
In my experience, I’ve seen countless plywood subfloors ruined by water damage. A leaky pipe, a spilled drink, or even high humidity can wreak havoc on plywood. While it’s a cost-effective option upfront, the potential for moisture damage can lead to costly repairs down the road.
Section 3: Introduction to Cement Board as a Subfloor Alternative
Now, let’s talk about cement board, the unsung hero of subflooring. It’s not as widely known as plywood, but it’s a fantastic alternative, especially when you’re thinking about the long-term health and safety of your family.
What is Cement Board?
Cement board is a composite material made of cement, reinforced with fibers. It’s typically available in sheets, similar to plywood, and is used as a substrate for tile, stone, and other flooring materials.
Unlike plywood, cement board is incredibly resistant to moisture, making it an ideal choice for areas prone to spills and humidity.
Historical Use and Evolution
Cement board has been used in construction for over a century. It was initially developed as a fireproof material for walls and ceilings. Over time, it has evolved into a versatile product used for a variety of applications, including subfloors, countertops, and exterior cladding.
The composition of cement board has also improved over the years. Modern cement boards are lighter, stronger, and easier to work with than their predecessors.
Why Cement Board is Gaining Popularity
Cement board is gaining popularity as a subfloor option for several reasons:
-
Moisture Resistance: As I mentioned, cement board is virtually impervious to water damage. This makes it an excellent choice for bathrooms, kitchens, and other areas where moisture is a concern.
-
Durability: Cement board is incredibly strong and durable. It can withstand heavy loads and resist impacts, making it ideal for high-traffic areas.
-
Mold Resistance: Because it doesn’t absorb moisture, cement board is resistant to mold and mildew growth. This is a huge benefit for families with allergies or respiratory problems.
-
Fire Resistance: Cement board is non-combustible and can help slow the spread of fire. This can provide an added layer of safety for your family.
-
Low Toxicity: Cement board is made from natural materials and doesn’t contain harmful chemicals. It doesn’t off-gas, making it a safe choice for indoor environments.
I’ve seen firsthand the benefits of using cement board in homes with kids. It’s incredibly resilient and can withstand the daily wear and tear of family life. Plus, the peace of mind that comes with knowing your subfloor is mold-resistant and non-toxic is priceless.
Section 4: Advantages of Cement Board Over Plywood
Let’s get down to the nitty-gritty: why should you choose cement board over plywood, especially when you have kids? Here’s a breakdown of the key advantages:
Moisture Resistance: No More Water Worries
This is where cement board really shines. Unlike plywood, cement board is virtually impervious to moisture. Spills, leaks, and humidity are no match for this material.
Think about it: kids spill things. It’s a fact of life. With plywood, a spilled glass of juice can seep into the subfloor, causing warping, rot, and mold growth. With cement board, you can simply wipe it up without worrying about lasting damage.
In fact, according to the Portland Cement Association, cement-based products are inherently resistant to water damage, making them ideal for wet environments.
Durability: Built to Last
Kids are tough on floors. They jump, run, and drop things. Cement board can handle the abuse. It’s incredibly strong and resistant to impacts, meaning it won’t crack or dent easily.
I’ve seen cement board subfloors that have lasted for decades, even in homes with active families. It’s a long-term investment that can save you money on repairs and replacements down the road.
Low Toxicity: A Healthier Home
As I mentioned earlier, some plywood contains adhesives that release VOCs. These chemicals can be harmful to your family’s health, especially children.
Cement board, on the other hand, is made from natural materials and doesn’t off-gas. It’s a safe and healthy choice for indoor environments.
According to the U.S. Green Building Council, using low-VOC materials can significantly improve indoor air quality and reduce the risk of health problems.
Fire Resistance: Added Safety
Cement board is non-combustible, meaning it won’t catch fire. This can provide an added layer of safety for your family in the event of a fire.
While I hope you never have to experience a fire in your home, knowing that your subfloor is fire-resistant can provide some peace of mind.
In fact, according to the National Fire Protection Association, cement-based materials can help slow the spread of fire and give you more time to evacuate.
Here’s a quick comparison table to summarize the advantages:
| Feature | Plywood | Cement Board |
|---|---|---|
| Moisture Resistance | Low | High |
| Durability | Moderate | High |
| Toxicity | May contain VOCs | Low, no off-gassing |
| Fire Resistance | Combustible | Non-combustible |
| Cost | Lower upfront | Higher upfront |
| Lifespan | Shorter (especially with water) | Longer (more resistant to water) |
While cement board may have a higher upfront cost, its long-term durability, moisture resistance, and safety benefits make it a worthwhile investment for families with children.
Section 5: Installation Process of Cement Board
Okay, so you’re convinced that cement board is the way to go. Let’s talk about how to install it. While I always recommend hiring a professional, here’s a general overview of the process:
Step-by-Step Guide
-
Preparation: Start by removing any existing flooring and cleaning the subfloor. Make sure the surface is level and free of debris.
-
Cutting: Cement board can be cut with a utility knife and a scoring tool. Score the board along the desired cut line and then snap it along the score.
-
Fastening: Attach the cement board to the floor joists using cement board screws. Space the screws every 6-8 inches along the edges and every 8-12 inches in the field.
-
Seaming: Apply cement board tape to the seams between the boards. This will help prevent cracking and ensure a smooth surface for your flooring.
-
Mortar: Apply a thin-set mortar over the cement board before installing your tile, stone, or other flooring material.
Tools Needed
- Utility knife
- Scoring tool
- Cement board screws
- Drill
- Cement board tape
- Thin-set mortar
- Trowel
- Safety glasses
- Dust mask
Safety Precautions
-
Always wear safety glasses and a dust mask when working with cement board. The dust can be irritating to your eyes and lungs.
-
Use caution when cutting cement board. The edges can be sharp.
-
Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for installing cement board.
Considerations for Families with Children
-
Keep children away from the work area during installation.
-
Store cement board and tools in a safe place, out of reach of children.
-
Clean up any dust or debris immediately after installation.
-
Ensure proper ventilation during and after installation to minimize exposure to dust and odors.
I always tell my clients that proper preparation is key to a successful cement board installation. Make sure your subfloor is clean, level, and structurally sound before you start. And don’t be afraid to ask for help if you’re not comfortable with any part of the process.
Section 6: Real-Life Examples and Testimonials
Don’t just take my word for it. Here are some stories from families who have made the switch from plywood to cement board subflooring:
Testimonial 1: The Spill-Proof Kitchen
“We have three young kids, so spills are a daily occurrence in our kitchen. We used to have plywood subflooring, and it was constantly getting damaged by water. We switched to cement board a few years ago, and it’s been a game-changer. We no longer have to worry about spills ruining our floors. Plus, it’s so easy to clean! We’re so glad we made the switch.” – Sarah, Mom of 3
Testimonial 2: Allergy-Friendly Home
“My son has severe allergies, so we’re very careful about the materials we use in our home. We learned that some plywood contains chemicals that can trigger his allergies. We decided to install cement board subflooring throughout our house, and it’s made a big difference. His allergies have improved, and we have peace of mind knowing that our home is safe for him.” – Mike, Dad of 1
Testimonial 3: Durable Playroom
“Our playroom gets a lot of use. The kids are always building forts, playing with toys, and running around. We needed a subfloor that could withstand the abuse. We chose cement board because it’s incredibly durable. It’s been two years, and it still looks like new! We’re so happy with our decision.” – Jessica, Mom of 2
Visual Examples
-
Photo: A bright, clean kitchen with cement board subflooring and tile flooring. The caption reads, “This kitchen is spill-proof thanks to cement board!”
-
Photo: A cozy playroom with cement board subflooring and soft carpet. The caption reads, “Cement board provides a durable foundation for this busy playroom.”
These are just a few examples of how cement board can benefit families with children. It’s a durable, moisture-resistant, and safe subfloor option that can provide peace of mind for years to come.
Conclusion
Choosing the right subfloor material is a crucial decision, especially when you’re creating a safe and healthy environment for your children. While plywood has been a traditional choice, cement board offers significant advantages, particularly in homes with kids.
From its superior moisture resistance to its durability, low toxicity, and fire resistance, cement board is a long-term investment that can protect your family’s health and well-being.
I encourage you to consider the benefits of cement board as a subfloor option for your home. While it may have a higher upfront cost, the long-term savings and peace of mind are well worth it.
Remember, your home is your family’s sanctuary. Choosing the right materials can make a big difference in their safety, comfort, and overall quality of life.
