Refinishing Hardwood Steps? (7 Costly Mistakes!)

Avoid These 7 Costly Mistakes!

Ever get that itch to transform a space in your home?

I know I have!

Sometimes, it hits you like a ton of bricks: “I need to refinish those hardwood steps!”

Maybe you’re picturing that rich, glowing wood underfoot, a total upgrade from the scuffed-up, tired look you’re currently rocking.

You grab your sander, ready to dive in, and wham!

Suddenly, those little imperfections you barely noticed before are screaming at you.

Deep scratches, weird grain patterns, color variations… where did those come from?

That’s when it hits you: refinishing hardwood steps is way more than just slapping on some new finish.

It’s a whole process, a dance of preparation, product knowledge, and patience.

And trust me, as a flooring contractor with years under my belt, I’ve seen plenty of DIY projects go south because of a few key mistakes.

That’s why I’m here to guide you.

We’re going to break down the seven most common (and costly!) mistakes people make when refinishing hardwood steps.

I’ll share my experiences, industry secrets, and practical tips to help you achieve stunning results without emptying your wallet.

Ready? Let’s get started!

1. Mistake #1: Skipping the Prep Work

Alright, let’s talk prep.

I cannot stress this enough: prep work is king!

Think of it like this: you wouldn’t paint a car without washing and sanding it first, right? Same deal here.

I’ve seen so many folks eager to jump straight to the fun part – applying the new finish – and completely skimp on the essential prep steps. Big mistake!

What exactly does “prep work” entail? Well, it’s a few things:

• Cleaning: This isn’t just a quick sweep. We’re talking deep cleaning. Use a wood cleaner specifically designed for hardwood floors. Get rid of all the dirt, grime, and old wax buildup. I often use a damp mop with a pH-neutral cleaner. Avoid excessive water! You don’t want to warp the wood. I like Bona’s Hardwood Floor Cleaner.

• Sanding: This is where you remove the old finish and create a smooth, even surface for the new finish to adhere to. You’ll likely need to use multiple grits of sandpaper, starting with a coarser grit to remove the old finish and then moving to finer grits to smooth out the wood.

  I typically start with an 80-grit paper to remove the old finish, then move to 120-grit, and finish with 180-grit for a super smooth surface.

  Pro Tip: Rent a good quality sander! Don’t cheap out on this. An orbital sander is usually best for beginners as it’s more forgiving than a drum sander.

  Be sure to get into the corners! A detail sander is your best friend here. I’ve used the Bosch Multi-X oscillating tool with a sanding attachment for years.

• Inspection: Once you’ve sanded, take a really good look at your steps. Are there any deep scratches or gouges that need to be filled? Are there any loose boards that need to be secured? Now is the time to address these issues.

  I often use a wood filler to repair minor imperfections. For larger damage, you might need to replace the damaged section of the step.

Why is all this prep so important?

Because if you skip it, you’re setting yourself up for problems down the road.

Think: poor adhesion of the new finish (leading to peeling), uneven color (because the old finish is still partially there), and a generally unprofessional-looking result.

I once had a client who insisted on skipping the sanding step. He figured he could just slap a new coat of polyurethane over the old, worn finish.

A few months later, the new finish started peeling up in sheets! He ended up having to pay me to redo the entire job, properly this time.

Trust me, taking the time to prep your steps correctly will save you time, money, and frustration in the long run.

2. Mistake #2: Choosing the Wrong Products

Okay, so you’ve prepped your steps, now it’s time to choose your weapons – I mean, your products!

This is another area where people often stumble. There are so many different types of finishes, sealers, and stains on the market, it can be overwhelming.

Let’s break it down:

• Finishes: This is the protective layer that goes on top of the stain (if you’re using one) and protects the wood from wear and tear.

  There are two main types of finishes: oil-based and water-based.

  • Oil-based finishes are more durable and tend to have a warmer, amber-like tone. However, they take longer to dry, have a stronger odor, and are less environmentally friendly.

  • Water-based finishes dry much faster, have a lower odor, and are more environmentally friendly. They are also less likely to yellow over time. However, they may not be as durable as oil-based finishes.

  I personally prefer water-based finishes for most projects. They’re easier to work with, dry quickly, and the technology has come a long way, making them very durable. My go-to is Bona Traffic HD.

• Sealers: Sealers are used to penetrate the wood grain and provide a base for the finish to adhere to. They also help to prevent the stain from penetrating too deeply into the wood.

  Some finishes are self-sealing, meaning you don’t need to apply a separate sealer. Check the manufacturer’s instructions.

  I often use a clear, water-based sealer before applying my finish. It helps to create a smooth, even surface and ensures good adhesion.

• Stains: Stains are used to change the color of the wood. They come in a wide variety of colors, from light and natural to dark and rich.

  When choosing a stain, consider the type of wood you’re working with and the overall look you’re trying to achieve.

  Always test the stain on a small, inconspicuous area before applying it to the entire project. This will give you a better idea of what the final color will look like.

  I’ve seen people choose a stain based on a picture on the can, only to be completely disappointed with the result. Always test!

So, what products should you avoid?

• Cheap, low-quality finishes: These finishes may be tempting because they’re inexpensive, but they’re usually not very durable and can yellow or scratch easily.

• Finishes that are not compatible with your existing finish: If you’re not sure what type of finish is currently on your steps, it’s best to test it before applying a new finish. You can do this by applying a small amount of the new finish to an inconspicuous area and seeing if it adheres properly.

• Stains that are too dark or too light for your wood: As I mentioned earlier, always test the stain before applying it to the entire project.

Choosing the right products is crucial for achieving a beautiful and durable finish.

Do your research, read reviews, and don’t be afraid to ask for help from a professional at your local hardware store.

3. Mistake #3: Ignoring the Wood Type

Did you know that not all wood is created equal?

It’s true! Different types of hardwood have different characteristics that can affect how they react to refinishing.

Understanding the type of wood you’re working with is essential for avoiding costly mistakes.

The biggest distinction to make is between softwood and hardwood.

• Hardwoods come from deciduous trees (trees that lose their leaves in the fall), such as oak, maple, and cherry. They are generally denser and more durable than softwoods.

• Softwoods come from coniferous trees (trees that have needles and cones), such as pine, fir, and cedar. They are generally less dense and more susceptible to scratches and dents.

Why does this matter for refinishing?

Well, hardwoods and softwoods absorb stain and finish differently.

Hardwoods, like oak, have open pores, which means they tend to absorb more stain. This can result in a richer, more vibrant color. However, it also means that you need to be careful not to over-stain the wood.

Softwoods, on the other hand, have closed pores and don’t absorb stain as easily. This can make it difficult to achieve a deep, even color. You may need to apply multiple coats of stain to get the desired result.

Also, softwoods are more prone to scratching and denting, so you’ll need to choose a more durable finish to protect them.

I once worked on a project where the homeowner assumed his steps were made of oak. He sanded them down and applied a dark walnut stain. The steps ended up looking way too dark and blotchy!

Turns out, the steps were actually made of pine. Because pine is a softwood, it absorbed the stain unevenly, resulting in a less-than-desirable finish.

I had to sand the steps down again and start over with a lighter stain that was better suited for softwood.

How can you tell what type of wood your steps are made of?

• Look at the grain: Hardwoods typically have a tighter, more intricate grain pattern than softwoods.

• Check the hardness: Hardwoods are generally harder and more difficult to dent than softwoods. You can try pressing your fingernail into the wood. If it leaves a noticeable indentation, it’s likely a softwood.

• Consult a professional: If you’re not sure what type of wood you’re working with, it’s best to consult with a flooring contractor or woodworker.

Once you know what type of wood you’re working with, you can choose the appropriate products and techniques to achieve the best possible results.

4. Mistake #4: Not Considering Foot Traffic

Think about your staircase.

Is it the main thoroughfare of your home?

Do kids race up and down it all day?

Or is it a more formal staircase that only gets used occasionally?

The amount of foot traffic your steps receive will have a big impact on the type of finish you should choose.

High-traffic areas require a more durable finish that can withstand the wear and tear of constant use.

If you choose a finish that’s not durable enough, it will quickly start to scratch, scuff, and wear away, leaving your steps looking worn and tired.

I’ve seen this happen countless times.

People choose a beautiful, matte finish because they love the look, but it’s not durable enough to hold up to the constant foot traffic. Within a year, the finish is completely worn off in the center of the steps.

So, what type of finish is best for high-traffic areas?

• Oil-based polyurethane: As I mentioned earlier, oil-based finishes are generally more durable than water-based finishes. Polyurethane is a particularly tough and abrasion-resistant finish that’s ideal for high-traffic areas.

• Water-based polyurethane: While not quite as durable as oil-based polyurethane, water-based polyurethane is still a good option for high-traffic areas, especially if you’re concerned about odor or environmental impact. Look for a high-quality, commercial-grade water-based polyurethane.

• Acrylic-urethane blends: These finishes combine the durability of polyurethane with the flexibility of acrylic, making them a good choice for steps that are subject to a lot of movement.

What about low-traffic areas?

If your steps don’t get a lot of use, you can get away with a less durable finish.

• Varnish: Varnish is a classic finish that provides a beautiful, glossy sheen. It’s not as durable as polyurethane, but it’s still a good option for low-traffic areas.

• Shellac: Shellac is a natural finish that’s made from the secretions of the lac beetle. It’s easy to apply and dries quickly, but it’s not very water-resistant and can be easily damaged by alcohol and other solvents. It’s best suited for decorative items that won’t be exposed to a lot of wear and tear.

In addition to choosing the right finish, you can also take steps to protect your steps from wear and tear.

• Use runners or rugs: Runners and rugs can help to protect your steps from scratches and scuffs, especially in high-traffic areas.

• Install stair treads: Stair treads are rubber or carpet strips that are attached to the surface of the steps. They provide extra traction and can help to prevent slips and falls.

• Clean your steps regularly: Regular cleaning can help to remove dirt and grime that can scratch and damage the finish.

By considering the level of foot traffic on your steps and choosing the appropriate finish and protective measures, you can ensure that your refinished steps will look beautiful for years to come.

5. Mistake #5: Rushing the Drying Process

Patience, my friend, is a virtue.

Especially when it comes to refinishing hardwood steps.

I know it’s tempting to rush through the drying process so you can get back to using your staircase, but trust me, it’s not worth it.

Rushing the drying process can lead to a whole host of problems, including:

• Bubbling: If the finish doesn’t have enough time to dry properly, it can trap air bubbles underneath the surface, resulting in a bumpy, uneven finish.

• Peeling: If the finish isn’t fully cured before you start walking on it, it can peel or chip easily.

• Uneven finish: Different areas of the finish may dry at different rates, resulting in an uneven sheen.

• Soft finish: If the finish doesn’t have enough time to cure, it will be softer and more susceptible to scratches and dents.

I remember one time, a homeowner was in a huge hurry to refinish his steps before a big party. He applied three coats of polyurethane in one day, without allowing enough drying time between coats.

The next day, the finish was still tacky and soft. He ended up having to sand the entire staircase down and start over!

How long should you wait between coats of finish?

The manufacturer’s instructions will provide the best guidance, but here are some general guidelines:

• Water-based finishes: Typically require 2-4 hours of drying time between coats.

• Oil-based finishes: Typically require 8-24 hours of drying time between coats.

Keep in mind that these are just general guidelines. The actual drying time may vary depending on the temperature, humidity, and ventilation in your home.

How can you tell if the finish is dry?

• Touch test: Gently touch the finish in an inconspicuous area. If it feels tacky or sticky, it’s not dry yet.

• Smell test: If you can still smell the strong odor of the finish, it’s likely not dry yet.

• Visual inspection: Look for any signs of bubbling, peeling, or unevenness.

Tips for speeding up the drying process:

• Ensure good ventilation: Open windows and doors to allow fresh air to circulate.

• Use a fan: A fan can help to speed up the drying process by circulating air.

• Maintain a consistent temperature: Avoid temperature fluctuations, as they can affect the drying time.

Don’t rush the drying process! It’s worth it to be patient and let each coat dry completely. Your hardwood steps will thank you!

6. Mistake #6: Failing to Follow Safety Protocols

Refinishing hardwood steps can be a rewarding project, but it’s important to remember that it involves working with potentially hazardous materials.

Failing to follow safety protocols can lead to health issues, accidents, and even serious injuries.

Here are some essential safety precautions to take:

• Ventilation: Proper ventilation is crucial when working with finishes, stains, and sealers. These products release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that can be harmful to your health.

  Open windows and doors to allow fresh air to circulate. Use a fan to help ventilate the area. If possible, work outdoors or in a well-ventilated garage.

• Protective gear: Always wear appropriate protective gear, including:

  • Respirator: A respirator will protect you from inhaling harmful VOCs. Choose a respirator that’s specifically designed for use with paints, stains, and finishes. I recommend a respirator with organic vapor cartridges.

  • Gloves: Wear chemical-resistant gloves to protect your skin from contact with finishes, stains, and sealers.

  • Eye protection: Wear safety glasses or goggles to protect your eyes from splashes and fumes.

  • Hearing protection: Sanding can be noisy, so wear earplugs or earmuffs to protect your hearing.

• Fire safety: Finishes, stains, and sealers are flammable. Keep them away from heat, sparks, and open flames.

  Store these products in a cool, dry, well-ventilated area. Dispose of rags and other materials that have been soaked in finish, stain, or sealer in a metal container with a tight-fitting lid.

• Chemical awareness: Read the manufacturer’s instructions carefully before using any finish, stain, or sealer. Understand the hazards associated with each product and follow the safety precautions listed on the label.

  If you experience any symptoms, such as dizziness, headache, or nausea, stop working immediately and get fresh air.

I had a friend who was refinishing his steps without wearing a respirator. He ended up getting sick from the fumes and had to go to the hospital!

Don’t take chances with your health. Always follow safety protocols when working with finishes, stains, and sealers.

7. Mistake #7: Overlooking Maintenance After Refinishing

You’ve done it! You’ve successfully refinished your hardwood steps and they look amazing.

But your work isn’t quite done yet.

Maintaining your refinished steps is essential for preserving their beauty and extending their lifespan.

Overlooking maintenance can lead to premature wear and tear, scratches, and other damage that can diminish the appearance of your steps and require you to refinish them again sooner.

Here are some tips for maintaining your refinished hardwood steps:

• Regular cleaning: Sweep or vacuum your steps regularly to remove dirt, dust, and debris. Use a soft-bristled brush or a vacuum with a floor attachment.

  Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaners, as they can damage the finish. Use a pH-neutral wood floor cleaner.

• Damp mopping: Occasionally damp mop your steps to remove stubborn dirt and grime. Use a microfiber mop and a small amount of wood floor cleaner.

  Avoid using too much water, as it can damage the wood. Make sure to dry the steps thoroughly after mopping.

• Protecting from scratches: Place mats or rugs at the top and bottom of the stairs to trap dirt and debris that can scratch the finish.

  Use furniture pads under the legs of any furniture that’s placed on the steps.

• Preventing water damage: Wipe up spills immediately to prevent water from soaking into the wood.

  Avoid using excessive water when cleaning the steps.

• Recoating: Depending on the amount of foot traffic your steps receive, you may need to recoat them every few years to maintain their finish.

  Recoating involves lightly sanding the steps and applying a new coat of finish. This can help to protect the wood from wear and tear and restore its luster.

I once had a client who refinished her steps and then completely neglected them. She never cleaned them, never used mats or rugs, and never wiped up spills. Within a few years, the finish was completely worn off and the steps looked even worse than they did before she refinished them!

Don’t let this happen to you.

Take care of your refinished hardwood steps and they will reward you with years of beauty and enjoyment.

Conclusion

So there you have it!

The seven most costly mistakes to avoid when refinishing hardwood steps.

Let’s recap:

1. Skipping the Prep Work: Prep is king! Clean, sand, and inspect thoroughly.

2. Choosing the Wrong Products: Select the right finishes, sealers, and stains for your specific needs.

3. Ignoring the Wood Type: Understand the differences between hardwood and softwood and choose products accordingly.

4. Not Considering Foot Traffic: Select a durable finish that can withstand the wear and tear of constant use.

5. Rushing the Drying Process: Be patient and allow each coat of finish to dry completely before applying the next.

6. Failing to Follow Safety Protocols: Protect yourself from harmful chemicals and fumes by wearing appropriate protective gear and ensuring good ventilation.

7. Overlooking Maintenance After Refinishing: Clean your steps regularly and take steps to protect them from scratches and damage.

By avoiding these common pitfalls, you can achieve stunning results and transform your staircase into a beautiful focal point in your home.

Remember, refinishing hardwood steps takes time, patience, and attention to detail. Don’t be afraid to take your time, do your research, and ask for help when you need it.

With a little knowledge and effort, you can achieve professional-looking results without breaking the bank.

Now go forth and create some beautiful, refinished hardwood steps!

Learn more