I remember early in my flooring career, a client asked me about “proprietary grade hardwood flooring.” Honestly, at first, it sounded like one of those fancy industry terms I’d hear but didn’t fully get. Over time, after installing hundreds of flooring projects and working closely with manufacturers, I realized how important understanding proprietary grades is—not just for pros like me but for anyone thinking about hardwood floors. It’s not just jargon; it can shape the look, feel, and cost of your entire flooring project.

If you’ve been wondering what makes proprietary grade hardwood flooring different from other hardwood options, or why you should care about the grading system on your new floor, stick around. I’ll walk you through everything I’ve learned—sharing personal stories, technical info, and even some data-backed insights—to help you make sense of it all.

What is Proprietary Grade Hardwood Flooring?

Let’s start with the basics: proprietary grade hardwood flooring is a grading system created and controlled by a specific brand or manufacturer to classify the quality and appearance of their hardwood products. Unlike traditional hardwood grading, which follows standard rules set by organizations like the National Wood Flooring Association (NWFA), proprietary grades are unique.

Think of it like this: traditional hardwood grades are like standardized school report cards—everyone uses the same grading scale. Proprietary grades are more like custom evaluations made by individual teachers who decide what’s excellent or average based on their own criteria.

This means that each company decides what counts as a “premium” or “select” grade based on characteristics like:

• How many knots and natural marks are allowed
• The amount of color variation permitted
• Grain uniformity or texture
• Presence of sapwood or mineral streaks
• Board length and width consistency

The goal is to give manufacturers flexibility to design flooring lines that reflect their brand’s style and quality standards. It also lets them offer floors that don’t fit neatly into existing grading categories—whether that means super-clean, almost flawless planks for a modern look or floors with rustic charm full of character marks.

My Experience Seeing Proprietary Grades in Action

I’ve installed floors from well-known brands that use proprietary grades extensively. One memorable project was a mid-century modern home where the homeowners wanted ultra-consistent wood color and grain to match their minimalist aesthetic. The manufacturer’s proprietary “Select Plus” grade was perfect—something I couldn’t find with regular NWFA grades.

At another time, I helped a family looking for a rustic farmhouse vibe choose a proprietary grade that allowed more knots and natural variations than typical rustic grades I’d used before. The result was a warm, lived-in feel that made the house truly their own.

Both projects taught me that proprietary grades aren’t just labels—they’re tools for designers and homeowners to get the exact look they want.

Why Grading Matters in Hardwood Flooring

You might be wondering why grading matters so much. After all, isn’t hardwood just hardwood?

Well, the grading system tells you how the wood looks and behaves—and that affects price, durability, maintenance, and style. It’s like buying fruit: some apples are perfectly round and red with no blemishes; others have spots or irregular shapes but taste great. Knowing the grade helps you set expectations.

Here’s what grading impacts:

• Appearance: Grades control how many knots, streaks, or color changes you’ll see.
• Durability: Some grades have more imperfections that could affect wear resistance.
• Price: Cleaner, more uniform wood tends to be pricier.
• Suitability: Certain grades work better in high-traffic areas or formal settings.
• Resale value: Unique or high-grade floors can add curb appeal and home value.

From my work experience, clients often underestimate how much differences in grading change the overall feel of their homes. When they see samples side-by-side, it’s clear right away why grades matter.

5 Must-Know Facts About Proprietary Grade Hardwood Flooring

1. Proprietary Grades Are Manufacturer-Specific and Not Standardized

This is probably the biggest point to understand: proprietary grades don’t follow any universal rules.

Whereas traditional hardwood grades have clear definitions—like FAS (First and Second) requiring 83% clear cuttings—proprietary grades are defined by each manufacturer’s internal standards. That means one company’s “Select” might allow more knots than another’s “Select.”

Why does this happen? Because brands want control over how their floors look and compete with unique textures and appearances. They can tweak grading rules to emphasize:

• More rustic features for character
• Ultra-smooth, consistent boards for modern designs
• Special wood sources or finishes

I once compared two proprietary grades labeled “Premium” from different manufacturers side-by-side on a job site. One had noticeably more visible knots and color variation than the other—even though both claimed “premium.” It was eye-opening.

The takeaway? Always ask your supplier or contractor for detailed grading specs—and see physical samples before deciding.

2. Proprietary Grades Offer More Aesthetic Variety

Because manufacturers create their own grading rules, they can produce flooring lines with very distinct looks not commonly found in traditional grades.

Whether you want:

• Wide planks with hand-scraped textures
• Boards with mineral streaks and natural color shifts
• Ultra-clear wood with minimal markings

Proprietary grades let companies deliver these styles consistently.

I remember helping a client pick floors for their lake house. They wanted something that felt natural but not too rough or rustic. We found a proprietary grade that featured subtle grain patterns and slight color variation—just enough to add warmth without appearing “knotty.” That balance would have been hard to achieve with a standard grade.

If you want your floor to stand out from cookie-cutter options, proprietary grades open up more possibilities.

3. Quality Can Vary Widely Between Brands

One downside of proprietary grading is quality inconsistency between manufacturers. Since standards aren’t unified, some companies may have stricter sorting processes or better finishes than others.

Over years of installations, I’ve tracked how different proprietary grades perform in real homes. One brand’s line had fewer warranty claims related to visible defects or premature finish wear compared to competitors’ proprietary grades marketed at similar price points.

In one study I compiled internally from over 50 jobs using three popular proprietary lines:

This reinforced how important it is to research brands carefully—not just rely on labels like “premium” or “select.”

When I recommend proprietary grade flooring today, I always highlight the importance of choosing reputable manufacturers who stand behind quality control.

4. Cost Differences Reflect Customization and Quality

Since proprietary grading involves additional sorting steps and customized criteria, these floors often cost more than traditional grades—even if they use similar wood species.

On average, based on my projects over the last five years:

• Traditional hardwood grades cost between $5 – $12 per sq.ft.
• Proprietary grades generally run $7 – $16 per sq.ft., depending on brand exclusivity and customization level.

The price bump comes from factors like:

• Extra labor sorting wood to meet custom standards
• Unique finishes or textures exclusive to the brand
• Limited availability or rare wood species tied to proprietary lines

To manage budgets effectively on my jobs, I use FloorTally—a digital tool that quickly calculates total flooring costs including materials, labor rates, waste factor, and local pricing nuances. This helps me present clients with realistic budgets upfront without surprises later.

FloorTally’s user-friendly interface lets me plug in proprietary grade selections alongside room dimensions and installation preferences to get accurate estimates within minutes. It’s saved me hours compared to manual calculations across multiple suppliers.

If you’re DIY-ing or working with contractors, tools like this can keep costs transparent when selecting more specialized flooring options like proprietary grades.

5. Installation and Maintenance Are Similar to Other Hardwood Floors

Even though proprietary grades differ in appearance or quality standards, installation methods don’t usually change much compared to other solid hardwood floors.

Key points I stress during install:

• Acclimate the wood properly—this minimizes expansion or contraction issues post-installation.
• Follow manufacturer instructions carefully for adhesives or nail-down techniques.
• Ensure subfloor is clean, dry, and level before laying boards.
• Maintain consistent humidity in the home to reduce warping risks.

Once installed, maintenance is pretty much standard hardwood care:

• Sweep or vacuum regularly to remove grit.
• Use damp mops sparingly; never soak wood.
• Avoid harsh chemicals that strip finish.
• Refinish every few years based on foot traffic wear patterns.

One thing I’ve noticed over the years is that some proprietary grades with more knots or character marks can hide minor scratches better than ultra-clear woods—which might be good for busy households with kids or pets.

Going Deeper: How Proprietary Grades Affect Hardwood Species Selection

Wood species play a huge role in your floor’s look and performance—and when combined with proprietary grading systems, it gets even more interesting.

Manufacturers often use proprietary grades to highlight certain species’ natural beauty uniquely:

• White Oak: A favorite for its durability; proprietary grades might showcase subtle grain variations or unique finishes emphasizing its warm tones.
• Maple: Known for smoothness; some brands offer proprietary maple lines with extra clarity and minimal knots.
• Hickory: Very rustic by nature; proprietary grades might embrace knots and color shifts as design elements rather than defects.
• Walnut: Darker species often graded highly due to natural richness; proprietary floors may focus on consistent color depth or hand-applied textures.

When I consult clients on species + proprietary grade combos, I always ask about lifestyle factors (kids? pets?), design goals (modern? rustic?), and budget constraints so we pick the best fit overall.

Case Study: A Custom Lakefront Home Flooring Project

Let me share a detailed example where choosing the right proprietary grade made all the difference:

A family building a new lakefront retreat wanted flooring that felt connected to nature but not overly rustic or rough. They disliked “knotty pine” looks but still wanted character—something warm yet elegant.

We explored several brands’ proprietary grade offerings:

• Brand X had a “Natural Select” grade allowing moderate knots but uneven color.
• Brand Y offered a “Clear Plus” grade focused on uniform grain but lacked texture.
• Brand Z had a “Signature Rustic” line with hand-scraped surfaces and balanced color variation.

After reviewing samples onsite under natural light over several days, the family chose Brand Z’s “Signature Rustic” line. It hit their sweet spot between warm character and sophistication.

Installation went smoothly—using FloorTally estimates we budgeted accurately for materials plus labor. The client was thrilled with the final look that immediately enhanced their home’s cozy vibe.

Breaking Down Hardwood Grading Terms You Might See Alongside Proprietary Grades

While proprietary grades themselves vary by brand, many companies still use familiar terms as part of naming conventions:

• Select Grade: Usually indicates cleaner boards with fewer defects.
• Rustic Grade: Boards may include more knots, streaks, or color variation.
• Clear Grade: Very few imperfections; often highest visual quality.
• Prime Grade: Sometimes used interchangeably with select or clear depending on brand.

If you see these terms attached to proprietary lines, ask what each means specifically for that product—there can be big differences hidden behind similar names.

How to Evaluate Samples Like a Pro

When shopping for any hardwood flooring—especially proprietary grades—I always encourage clients (and friends) to do this simple test:

1. View samples in different lighting: Morning sunlight vs evening lamp light can show different tones.
2. Inspect grain patterns closely: Are knots tight or loose? Are there cracks?
3. Check plank edges: Are boards straight? Any warping?
4. Lay several planks side by side: See how much variation exists across multiple boards.
5. Ask about finish types: Matte vs gloss can change appearance dramatically.
6. Touch and feel texture: Smooth surface vs hand-scraped will affect wear experience.

These steps helped me avoid surprises many times—and they’ll help you too if buying flooring yourself.

What About Engineered Hardwood?

While this article focuses on solid hardwood with proprietary grades mostly applied there, manufacturers sometimes extend proprietary grading concepts into engineered hardwood lines too. The same principles apply:

• Each brand sets its own rules for appearance quality
• Color variation and imperfections graded differently than traditional hardwood
• Price premium reflects customization

If you’re considering engineered hardwood with proprietary grading terminology, check carefully whether core materials differ in quality as well since engineered layers impact durability differently than solid wood.

Final Thoughts from My Flooring Toolbox

Over my years working hands-on with flooring projects across residential homes—from cozy cottages to upscale urban condos—I’ve learned one thing: knowing exactly what you’re buying matters immensely when it comes to hardwood floors.

Proprietary grade hardwood flooring can provide beautiful, unique options beyond standard industry categories—but only if you understand what each brand offers behind the label.

Wanting consistency? Look for brands with strict sorting rules and solid warranties. Craving rustic charm? Some proprietary lines embrace knots and grain variation as features. Budget-conscious? Use tools like FloorTally early in your planning process so you know what you’re getting into financially—and avoid sticker shock later on.

At the end of the day, your floor is a big part of your home’s personality—and choosing smartly pays off in enjoyment for years.

If you have questions about specific brands’ proprietary grades—or want help estimating your next flooring project—I’m always happy to chat and share what I know from hands-on experience. Just reach out anytime!

Thanks for sticking around! What kind of hardwood floors are you thinking about? Rustic? Clean? Something totally unique? Let me know—I love talking shop about wood flooring!

Learn more