Baking Soda Cleaner? (1 Pro Warns: DON’T!)

Ever walk into your kitchen after a serious cooking session? Or maybe peek into the bathroom after the kids have had their fun?

Cleaning products EVERYWHERE, right? You just want a clean, fresh space, but the sheer number of chemical-filled bottles can be totally overwhelming.

That’s where baking soda comes in. It’s the go-to “natural” solution for so many people. But here’s the thing: I’m a flooring contractor and I’ve seen things. Things baking soda shouldn’t be used on.

I’m here to tell you that, in some cases, this “miracle” cleaner might be doing more harm than good. Let’s dive in!

Section 1: The Allure of Baking Soda

Baking soda, or sodium bicarbonate, has been a household staple for, well, forever. Think about it: your grandma probably used it, your mom probably used it, and you’re probably using it right now! It’s been around since the 1840s when two bakers started producing it in NYC.

It’s cheap, readily available, and touted as a “natural” cleaner. But why is it so popular? It’s incredibly versatile!

• Kitchen: From scrubbing burnt pots and pans to deodorizing the fridge, baking soda is a kitchen workhorse.
• Bathroom: Soap scum on tiles? Clogged drain? Baking soda to the rescue!
• Carpets: Sprinkle it on, let it sit, vacuum it up. Supposedly, it banishes odors like magic.

I’ve heard tons of success stories. “I cleaned my oven with baking soda and it looks brand new!” “My carpets smell so fresh after using baking soda!” “It’s the only thing that gets rid of the coffee stains in my mugs!”

But what makes baking soda actually work? It’s all about the chemistry. Baking soda is a mild alkali. This means it can react with acids to neutralize them.

It’s also a gentle abrasive. Think of it as a very fine sandpaper. This helps to lift dirt and grime without being too harsh.

But even with all these benefits, there’s a catch.

Section 2: The Warning from the Pro

Okay, let’s get down to brass tacks. I’ve been a flooring contractor for over 15 years. I’ve seen it all: the good, the bad, and the downright ugly.

And I’m here to tell you that baking soda isn’t always the miracle cleaner it’s cracked up to be.

My biggest concern? It’s abrasiveness. Yes, it’s gentle, but on certain surfaces, it can cause real damage.

Think about it: you’re scrubbing away, thinking you’re doing a great job, but microscopic scratches are happening. Over time, these scratches can dull the finish on your floors, countertops, and even appliances.

Specific scenarios where baking soda can cause harm:

• Hardwood Floors: Baking soda can dull the finish, especially on softer woods like pine.
• Certain Countertops: Marble, granite, and other natural stone surfaces can be scratched by abrasive cleaners.
• Acrylic and Fiberglass: Tubs and showers can lose their shine due to micro-scratches.
• Certain Metals: Polished metals can be damaged.
• Grout: Can erode the Grout over time, causing structural weakness.

Common mistakes homeowners make:

• Using too much baking soda: More isn’t always better. A little goes a long way.
• Scrubbing too hard: Let the baking soda do the work. Don’t apply excessive pressure.
• Not rinsing thoroughly: Residue can build up and attract more dirt.
• Using it on delicate surfaces without testing: Always test in an inconspicuous area first.

I remember one client who used a baking soda paste to clean their marble countertop. They scrubbed and scrubbed, thinking they were getting rid of a stain. When I came in to replace the flooring, I noticed the countertop!

The result? A dull, scratched surface that needed professional polishing. And that’s not cheap, folks.

Another time, a homeowner used baking soda to “freshen up” their hardwood floors. After a few months, the finish looked cloudy and worn. They had to refinish the entire floor!

These aren’t isolated incidents. I’ve seen this happen repeatedly.

Section 3: Alternative Cleaning Solutions

So, if baking soda isn’t always the answer, what are the alternatives?

Luckily, there are plenty of natural and eco-friendly options that can get the job done without the risk of damage.

• Vinegar: A natural disinfectant and degreaser. Great for cleaning glass, removing hard water stains, and deodorizing.
  • Pros: Cheap, readily available, effective.
  • Cons: Strong odor, not suitable for all surfaces (like natural stone).
• Lemon Juice: A natural bleaching agent and deodorizer. Perfect for removing stains and brightening surfaces.
  • Pros: Pleasant scent, effective stain remover.
  • Cons: Can be acidic and damage certain surfaces, like marble.
• Castile Soap: A gentle, all-purpose cleaner made from vegetable oils.
  • Pros: Gentle, effective, versatile.
  • Cons: Can leave a residue if not rinsed properly.
• Commercial Eco-Friendly Cleaners: Many brands offer plant-based, non-toxic cleaners that are safe for your home and the environment.
  • Pros: Convenient, effective, often formulated for specific surfaces.
  • Cons: Can be more expensive than DIY options.

I often recommend a simple vinegar and water solution for cleaning floors. It’s effective, cheap, and doesn’t leave a residue. Just be sure to use it sparingly on hardwood and avoid it altogether on natural stone.

For tougher stains, I suggest a paste made from castile soap and water. It’s gentle enough for most surfaces but still has enough cleaning power to tackle stubborn grime.

Section 4: Scientific Studies and Expert Opinions

So, what does the science say about baking soda as a cleaner?

While there aren’t a ton of studies specifically on baking soda’s cleaning properties, there is some research that sheds light on its effectiveness.

A study published in the “Journal of Environmental Health” found that baking soda can be effective at killing certain types of bacteria and fungi. This supports its use as a disinfectant and deodorizer.

However, other studies have shown that baking soda is not as effective as commercial cleaners at killing certain pathogens. This means it may not be the best choice for disinfecting surfaces that are heavily contaminated.

I spoke with a chemist, Dr. Emily Carter, about the potential risks of using baking soda as a cleaner. She explained that while baking soda is generally safe, it can react with certain substances to create harmful compounds.

“For example, mixing baking soda with vinegar creates carbon dioxide gas,” Dr. Carter explained. “In a closed container, this can cause pressure to build up and potentially explode.”

She also cautioned against using baking soda on delicate surfaces. “Baking soda is a mild abrasive, but it can still scratch or dull the finish on certain materials,” she said.

According to the EPA, you can visit their Safer Choice Standard to see what products are safe for the environment and their users.

Section 5: Personal Stories and Case Studies

Let’s get real for a minute. I want to share some stories from people who have used baking soda for cleaning, both good and bad.

• Sarah’s Story: “I used baking soda to clean my oven, and it worked like a charm! I made a paste with water, spread it all over the inside, let it sit overnight, and then scrubbed it clean. It was so much easier than using those harsh oven cleaners.”
• Mark’s Story: “I tried using baking soda to clean my granite countertops, and it left them looking dull and scratched. I had to call a professional to polish them, and it cost me a fortune!”
• Lisa’s Story: “I used baking soda to deodorize my carpet, and it worked great. I sprinkled it on, let it sit for a few hours, and then vacuumed it up. The smell was gone, and my carpet looked refreshed.”
• David’s Story: “I mixed baking soda with vinegar to clean my drain, and it created a huge mess. The mixture foamed up and overflowed, and it didn’t even unclog the drain. I ended up having to call a plumber.”

These stories highlight the importance of understanding the potential risks and benefits of using baking soda as a cleaner. It can be effective in certain situations, but it’s not always the best choice.

Section 6: Conclusion

So, what’s the bottom line? Baking soda can be a useful cleaning agent, but it’s not a miracle solution. It has its limitations and potential drawbacks.

While it’s tempting to reach for that box of baking soda as a quick and easy cleaning solution, it’s important to understand the potential risks. It’s cheap, readily available and can be used in a variety of scenarios.

Remember my warning, don’t just blindly follow the hype. Consider the surface you’re cleaning, the potential for damage, and the alternatives available.

Ultimately, the best cleaning solution is the one that’s safest and most effective for your specific needs. So, do your research, test in an inconspicuous area, and don’t be afraid to try something new.

Happy cleaning!

Learn more