Hardwood Flooring: Know This! (8 Costly Mistakes!)

(8 Costly Mistakes!)

Introduction: The Seasonal Appeal

of Hardwood Flooring

As a seasoned flooring contractor, I’ve seen firsthand the transformation hardwood floors can bring to a home.

The rich tones and natural beauty are especially appealing as we head into the cooler months.

Homeowners often look to upgrade their spaces, seeking that cozy, inviting atmosphere.

But let me tell you, installing hardwood is not always a walk in the park.

I’ve witnessed countless projects where well-intentioned homeowners made mistakes that cost them dearly.

From choosing the wrong type of wood to neglecting essential maintenance, the pitfalls are numerous.

That’s why I’m writing this – to help you avoid those common and expensive blunders.

Whether you’re a DIY enthusiast or planning to hire a professional, this guide will equip you with the knowledge to make informed decisions.

Let’s dive into eight of the most common and costly hardwood flooring mistakes, and how to sidestep them.

Section 1: Choosing the Wrong Type

of Hardwood

One of the first and most significant decisions you’ll make is selecting the right type of hardwood.

Are you thinking of going with a solid or engineered option?

It may seem straightforward, but trust me, it’s not.

Solid Hardwood: This is the classic choice – planks made from a single piece of wood.

It’s beautiful, durable, and can be refinished multiple times.

However, solid hardwood is sensitive to moisture and temperature fluctuations.

I usually advise against installing it in basements or bathrooms.

Engineered Hardwood: This consists of multiple layers of wood veneer bonded together.

It’s more stable than solid hardwood and can handle humidity changes better.

Engineered hardwood is a great option for basements, kitchens, and other areas prone to moisture.

Climate Considerations: Where you live plays a crucial role.

In areas with high humidity, like the Southeast, engineered hardwood is often the safer bet.

In drier climates, solid hardwood might be perfectly fine.

Species Selection: Not all wood species are created equal.

Some are harder and more durable than others.

The Janka hardness scale measures the resistance of wood to denting and wear. (Source: NWFA – National Wood Flooring Association)

Here’s a quick look at some popular species and their Janka ratings:

For high-traffic areas, like hallways and living rooms, I recommend choosing a species with a higher Janka rating.

Avoid softer woods, like pine, which are more prone to dents and scratches.

I once had a client who insisted on installing cherry hardwood in their entryway.

Within a year, it was riddled with dents from shoes and dropped items.

They ended up replacing it with a more durable option, costing them a small fortune.

Section 2: Ignoring Acclimation Needs

Okay, you’ve picked out your dream hardwood – great!

But hold on, you can’t just slap it down right away.

Acclimation is a crucial step that many homeowners overlook, and it can lead to serious problems down the line.

What is Acclimation? It’s the process of allowing the hardwood to adjust to the temperature and humidity levels of your home before installation.

Wood is a natural material, and it expands and contracts with changes in moisture content.

If you install hardwood that hasn’t acclimated, it could warp, cup, or gap after installation.

Consequences of Skipping Acclimation: Trust me, I’ve seen it all.

Gaps between planks, cupping (where the edges of the planks rise), and even buckling are common consequences.

These issues not only look bad but can also be expensive to repair.

The Acclimation Process: So, how do you properly acclimate hardwood?

1. Bring the wood into your home: Stack the boxes of hardwood in the room where it will be installed.

2. Allow air circulation: Space the boxes apart to allow air to circulate around them.

3. Monitor humidity: Use a hygrometer to monitor the humidity levels in your home.

   Ideally, you want the humidity to be within the range recommended by the wood manufacturer (usually 30-50%).

4. Wait: The acclimation period typically lasts for 3-5 days, but it can take longer depending on the wood species and the environmental conditions.

I remember one project where the homeowner was in a rush to get the floors installed before a big party.

They skipped the acclimation process, and within a few weeks, the floors started to cup.

They had to pay me to rip up the entire floor and start over, this time with proper acclimation.

Section 3: Overlooking Subfloor Preparation

Your subfloor is the foundation for your hardwood, so it needs to be in tip-top shape.

Ignoring subfloor preparation is like building a house on a shaky foundation – it’s just asking for trouble.

Why is Subfloor Prep Important? A level, clean, and dry subfloor is essential for a successful hardwood installation.

If the subfloor is uneven, the hardwood planks won’t lay flat, leading to squeaks, gaps, and uneven wear.

Moisture in the subfloor can cause the hardwood to warp, cup, or even rot.

Common Subfloor Issues:

• Moisture: This is the biggest enemy of hardwood.

  Use a moisture meter to check the moisture content of the subfloor.

  It should be within the range recommended by the wood manufacturer (usually below 12%).

  If the moisture level is too high, you’ll need to identify and fix the source of the moisture before installing the hardwood.

• Levelness: Use a long level or a straightedge to check for any dips or humps in the subfloor.

  Any variations greater than 3/16 inch over a 10-foot span should be corrected.

• Cleanliness: Remove any debris, dust, or old adhesive from the subfloor.

  A clean surface will ensure proper adhesion of the hardwood.

Step-by-Step Subfloor Preparation:

1. Inspect: Thoroughly inspect the subfloor for any signs of damage, moisture, or unevenness.

2. Clean: Sweep, vacuum, or scrape the subfloor to remove any debris.

3. Level: Use a self-leveling compound to fill in any dips or low spots.

   Grind down any high spots with a concrete grinder.

4. Moisture Test: Perform a moisture test to ensure the subfloor is dry enough for hardwood installation.

5. Underlayment (optional): Consider installing an underlayment to provide additional moisture protection, sound insulation, and cushioning.

I had a client who tried to save money by skipping the subfloor preparation.

They installed hardwood over an uneven subfloor, and within a few months, the floors started to squeak and buckle.

They ended up having to tear up the entire floor and redo the subfloor properly, which cost them even more in the long run.

Section 4: Skimping on Quality Installation

Alright, you’ve got the right wood, you’ve acclimated it properly, and you’ve prepped the subfloor.

Now comes the installation – and this is where things can really go wrong if you’re not careful.

DIY vs. Professional: I understand the temptation to save money by installing hardwood yourself.

But let me tell you, it’s not as easy as it looks.

Proper hardwood installation requires specialized tools, knowledge, and experience.

A professional installer will ensure that the floors are installed correctly, with proper spacing, alignment, and fastening.

They’ll also be able to handle any unexpected issues that may arise during the installation process.

Common Installation Mistakes:

• Gaps: Gaps between planks can occur if the hardwood is not properly acclimated or if the installer doesn’t leave enough expansion space.

• Uneven Planks: Uneven planks can be caused by an uneven subfloor or improper installation techniques.

• Poor Sealing: If the hardwood is not properly sealed, it can be vulnerable to moisture damage and staining.

Long-Term Impacts of Poor Installation: Poorly installed hardwood can lead to a host of problems, including:

• Squeaking: Squeaky floors are annoying and can be a sign of loose planks or an uneven subfloor.

• Buckling: Buckling occurs when the hardwood expands and has nowhere to go, causing it to lift off the subfloor.

• Premature Wear: Improperly installed hardwood is more prone to wear and tear, reducing its lifespan.

I once had to fix a floor where the homeowner tried to install it themselves.

The cost to repair the damage was more than it would have cost to hire a professional installer in the first place.

Section 5: Neglecting Maintenance and Care

You’ve got your beautiful hardwood floors installed – now what?

Well, it’s not a “set it and forget it” situation.

Proper maintenance and care are essential to keep your floors looking their best for years to come.

Maintenance Requirements: The maintenance requirements vary depending on the type of finish you have.

• Surface Finishes (Polyurethane): These are the most common type of finish and are relatively easy to maintain.

  Regular sweeping and vacuuming are essential to remove dirt and debris.

  You can also use a damp mop with a wood floor cleaner specifically designed for polyurethane finishes.

• Penetrating Oil Finishes: These finishes penetrate the wood and provide a natural look and feel.

  They require regular oiling to maintain their protective properties.

  Avoid using water or harsh chemicals on these floors.

Consequences of Neglecting Maintenance: Neglecting maintenance can lead to costly repairs or replacements.

Dirt and grit can scratch the finish, leading to dullness and wear.

Moisture can damage the wood, causing it to warp, cup, or rot.

Seasonal Maintenance Checklist:

• Spring: Deep clean the floors to remove any accumulated dirt and grime from the winter months.

• Summer: Use area rugs in high-traffic areas to protect the floors from wear and tear.

• Fall: Check for any gaps or cracks in the floors and repair them as needed.

• Winter: Use a humidifier to maintain proper humidity levels in your home and prevent the wood from drying out.

I had a client who never bothered to clean their hardwood floors properly.

Over time, the finish became dull and scratched, and the floors looked old and worn.

They eventually had to refinish the entire floor, which was a major expense.

Section 6: Choosing the Wrong Finish

The finish you choose for your hardwood floors not only affects their appearance but also their durability and maintenance requirements.

Finishing Options:

• Oil-Based Polyurethane: This is a durable and long- lasting finish that provides a warm, amber hue.

  It’s resistant to scratches and stains but can yellow over time.

• Water-Based Polyurethane: This is a more eco-friendly option that dries quickly and doesn’t yellow over time.

  It’s less durable than oil-based polyurethane but still provides good protection.

• Matte Finish: This finish provides a low-sheen look that hides scratches and dirt well.

  It’s a popular choice for modern homes.

• Gloss Finish: This finish provides a high-sheen look that reflects light and makes the floors appear brighter.

  It shows scratches and dirt more easily than matte finishes.

Impact of Wrong Finish: Choosing the wrong finish can affect the durability and appearance of your floors.

A finish that’s not durable enough for your lifestyle can wear quickly, requiring frequent refinishing.

A finish that’s too glossy can show every scratch and speck of dust.

Guidance on Selecting the Right Finish: Consider your lifestyle and the amount of traffic your floors will receive.

For high-traffic areas, choose a durable finish like oil-based polyurethane or a water-based polyurethane with multiple coats.

If you have pets or young children, choose a finish that’s resistant to scratches and stains.

If you prefer a more natural look, consider a matte finish or a penetrating oil finish.

I once had a client who wanted a high-gloss finish for their kitchen floors.

They loved the way it looked at first, but within a few weeks, it was covered in scratches and smudges.

They ended up having to refinish the floors with a matte finish, which was more forgiving.

Section 7: Failing to Consider Environmental Factors

Hardwood is a natural material, and it’s sensitive to environmental factors like humidity and temperature.

Failing to consider these factors can lead to problems like warping, cupping, and gapping.

Impact of Humidity and Temperature:

• Humidity: High humidity can cause the wood to expand, while low humidity can cause it to contract.

  This can lead to gaps between planks or buckling of the floors.

• Temperature: Extreme temperature changes can also affect the wood, causing it to expand and contract.

Seasonal Changes: Seasonal changes can have a significant impact on hardwood floors.

In the winter, when the air is dry, the wood can shrink, leading to gaps.

In the summer, when the air is humid, the wood can expand, leading to buckling.

Mitigating Environmental Factors:

• Maintain Proper Humidity Levels: Use a humidifier in the winter to maintain proper humidity levels in your home (usually 30-50%).

• Control Temperature: Avoid extreme temperature changes by using a thermostat to regulate the temperature in your home.

• Proper Acclimation: Ensure that the hardwood is properly acclimated to the temperature and humidity levels in your home before installation.

I had a client who lived in a very dry climate.

They didn’t use a humidifier in the winter, and their hardwood floors developed large gaps between the planks.

They ended up having to fill the gaps with wood filler, which was a temporary solution.

Section 8: Ignoring Soundproofing Needs

If you live in a multi-story home or an apartment building, soundproofing is an important consideration.

Hardwood floors can transmit sound easily, which can be annoying for you and your neighbors.

Why is Soundproofing Essential? Soundproofing can reduce the amount of noise that travels through the floors, creating a more peaceful and comfortable living environment.

Common Mistakes Related to Soundproofing:

• Not Using an Underlayment: An underlayment can provide a layer of cushioning and sound absorption.

• Using the Wrong Type of Underlayment: Not all underlayments are created equal.

  Choose an underlayment that’s specifically designed for soundproofing.

• Not Sealing Gaps: Gaps around the perimeter of the room can allow sound to travel through.

Effective Soundproofing Solutions:

• Install a Soundproof Underlayment: Look for an underlayment with a high Sound Transmission Class (STC) rating.

• Seal Gaps: Use acoustic caulk to seal any gaps around the perimeter of the room.

• Add Rugs and Carpets: Rugs and carpets can absorb sound and reduce noise transmission.

I once had a client who lived in an apartment building.

They installed hardwood floors without soundproofing, and their downstairs neighbors complained about the noise.

They ended up having to tear up the floors and install a soundproof underlayment, which was a major hassle.

Conclusion: Avoiding Costly Mistakes

for a Successful Hardwood Flooring Project

So, there you have it – eight costly mistakes to avoid when it comes to hardwood flooring.

From choosing the right type of wood to proper maintenance, each step is crucial for a successful project.

Remember, careful planning, proper installation, and ongoing maintenance are key to ensuring that your hardwood floors enhance your home for years to come.

Don’t rush the process, and don’t be afraid to seek advice from professionals when needed.

Your beautiful, durable hardwood floors will be worth the effort!

Learn more