Murphy Oil On Hardwood? (7 Pro Warnings!)

It’s amusing how a product marketed for its gentle cleaning ability can lead to flooring disasters that make homeowners question their life choices.

Enter Murphy Oil Soap—a beloved staple in many households that promises a shine and cleanliness but often leaves behind a trail of cautionary tales.

Introduction

Murphy Oil Soap. You’ve probably seen it. Maybe even used it.

It’s been around for ages, promising a gentle, natural way to clean your hardwood floors.

And let’s be honest, the idea of using something “natural” on our beautiful hardwood floors is super appealing, right?

We want to protect them, keep them looking their best. I mean, who doesn’t want that warm, inviting gleam underfoot?

Many homeowners swear by Murphy Oil Soap. They love the scent, the perceived “gentle” cleaning action, and the promise of a natural solution.

But here’s the thing: while it might seem like a harmless, even beneficial, product, there are significant drawbacks that you need to be aware of.

As a flooring contractor with years of experience, I’ve seen firsthand the issues that can arise from using Murphy Oil Soap on hardwood floors.

And trust me, some of them aren’t pretty. So, before you reach for that bottle, let’s dive into the potential pitfalls.

I’m going to share 7 pro warnings that could save you a lot of headaches—and a lot of money—down the road.

Section 1: The Allure of Murphy Oil Soap

Let’s rewind a bit and talk about why Murphy Oil Soap is so popular in the first place.

Where did it come from? What makes it so appealing?

Well, Murphy Oil Soap has a long history. It was first created way back in the early 1900s.

The original formula was based on vegetable oils, which gave it that “natural” appeal right from the start.

Over the years, Murphy Oil Soap has masterfully marketed itself as a gentle, all-purpose cleaner, perfectly safe for hardwood floors.

Think about the commercials you’ve seen. Images of sparkling clean floors, happy families, and the promise of a naturally beautiful home.

It’s a powerful message! And it’s easy to see why so many people have been drawn to it.

But the appeal goes beyond just marketing. There are a few key attributes that make Murphy Oil Soap so attractive to consumers:

• “Natural” Ingredients: The perception that it’s made from natural ingredients is a big draw. In a world full of harsh chemicals, something that sounds like it comes from nature is instantly appealing.

• Pleasant Scent: Let’s be honest, the scent is pretty nice. It’s a clean, fresh smell that leaves your house smelling, well, clean!

• Ease of Use: It’s easy to find, easy to use, and promises a quick and simple cleaning solution.

• Tradition: For many families, using Murphy Oil Soap is a tradition. It’s what their parents and grandparents used, so they assume it’s the right thing to do.

I get it. I really do. The allure is strong. But it’s important to look beyond the marketing and understand the potential risks.

Section 2: The Science of Hardwood Flooring

Before we get into the specific warnings, let’s take a quick detour into the science of hardwood flooring.

Understanding how your floors are constructed and finished is crucial to choosing the right cleaning products.

Hardwood flooring isn’t just one monolithic slab of wood. There are different types, different finishes, and different maintenance needs.

Generally, we can categorize hardwood flooring into two main types:

• Solid Hardwood: This is exactly what it sounds like—planks made from a single piece of wood. It’s durable, long-lasting, and can be refinished multiple times.

• Engineered Hardwood: This consists of a thin layer of hardwood veneer glued to a core of plywood or other composite material. It’s more resistant to moisture than solid hardwood and is often a more affordable option.

Then there’s the finish. This is the protective layer that sits on top of the wood and determines its appearance and durability.

The finish also dictates how you should clean and maintain your floors.

The two most common types of finishes are:

• Oil-Based Finishes: These finishes provide a warm, rich look and are known for their durability. They penetrate the wood, offering protection from within.

• Water-Based Finishes: These finishes are more environmentally friendly and dry faster than oil-based finishes. They tend to be clearer and show the natural color of the wood more vividly.

So, why is all of this important? Because the finish is the barrier that protects the wood from damage.

And different finishes react differently to different cleaning agents.

For example, some finishes are more susceptible to water damage, while others can be dulled by harsh chemicals.

The key takeaway here is that you need to know what type of finish you have on your floors before you start cleaning them with anything.

If you’re not sure, consult with a flooring professional. It’s better to be safe than sorry.

Now, with that foundational knowledge in place, let’s get to those warnings about Murphy Oil Soap.

Section 3: Warning #1 – Residue Buildup

Alright, let’s kick things off with the first and perhaps most common issue: residue buildup.

This is where Murphy Oil Soap starts to show its dark side.

While it might seem like you’re cleaning your floors, what’s often happening is that you’re leaving behind a thin layer of oily residue.

Over time, this residue attracts dirt, dust, and grime like a magnet.

And the more you use Murphy Oil Soap, the more the residue builds up. It’s a vicious cycle!

I’ve seen floors that look dull, hazy, and even sticky to the touch because of this residue.

It’s not a pretty sight.

The problem is that Murphy Oil Soap isn’t really “cleaning” in the traditional sense. It’s more like coating the floor with a thin layer of oil.

This oil can trap dirt and make it harder to remove.

Think of it like this: imagine you’re trying to clean a greasy pan with just oil. It’s not going to work, right?

You need soap and water to cut through the grease and remove the dirt.

Murphy Oil Soap, despite its name, doesn’t really do that.

I remember one client in particular who had been using Murphy Oil Soap on her hardwood floors for years.

She loved the scent and thought it was keeping her floors clean.

But when I came in to give her an estimate for refinishing, I immediately noticed the problem.

Her floors were covered in a thick, sticky residue.

It was so bad that it was actually difficult to walk on without feeling like your shoes were sticking to the floor.

She was shocked when I told her that the residue was actually making her floors dirtier than they would have been if she had just used plain water.

And that’s the thing: sometimes, less is more.

Section 4: Warning #2 – Slippery Surfaces

Okay, so now you know about the residue buildup. But that’s not the only problem. Another major concern is slippery surfaces.

Have you ever noticed that your floors feel a little slick after using Murphy Oil Soap?

That’s because the oily residue can create a slippery film on the surface of the wood.

This can be especially dangerous for elderly people, children, or anyone with mobility issues.

According to the National Safety Council, falls are a leading cause of injury and death in the United States.

And slippery floors are a major contributing factor.

While I don’t have specific statistics on falls related to Murphy Oil Soap use, it’s not hard to imagine how the slippery residue could increase the risk of accidents.

I’ve heard countless stories from homeowners who have slipped and fallen on floors cleaned with Murphy Oil Soap.

Some have even suffered serious injuries.

One woman told me that she slipped and broke her wrist after cleaning her kitchen floor with Murphy Oil Soap.

She had been using it for years and never thought it could be dangerous.

But the truth is, any product that leaves behind an oily residue can create a slip hazard.

If you’re concerned about slippery floors, there are several things you can do:

• Use a different cleaning product: Choose a cleaner that is specifically designed for hardwood floors and doesn’t leave behind a residue.

• Use a microfiber mop: Microfiber mops are great at picking up dirt and grime without leaving behind excess moisture.

• Dry the floor thoroughly: After cleaning, make sure to dry the floor thoroughly with a clean, dry towel.

• Consider a non-slip floor treatment: There are several products on the market that can add a non-slip coating to your hardwood floors.

Section 5: Warning #3 – Dulling the Finish

Let’s talk about shine. Or, more accurately, the lack of shine.

One of the biggest complaints I hear from homeowners who use Murphy Oil Soap is that it dulls the finish of their hardwood floors over time.

They start out with beautiful, glossy floors, but after repeated use of Murphy Oil Soap, the finish becomes cloudy and lackluster.

Why does this happen? Well, it’s a combination of factors.

First, the residue buildup we talked about earlier can create a hazy film on the surface of the floor, which reduces its reflectivity.

Second, the oil in Murphy Oil Soap can actually break down the finish over time, causing it to lose its luster.

I’ve seen floors that were once vibrant and gleaming become dull and lifeless after just a few years of using Murphy Oil Soap.

It’s a gradual process, so you might not notice it right away.

But eventually, you’ll start to see a noticeable difference in the appearance of your floors.

One way to think about it is like this: imagine you’re washing your car with a soapy water that leaves a film.

Over time, that film will dull the paint and make it look less shiny.

The same thing happens with Murphy Oil Soap and your hardwood floors.

I had another client who was convinced that her floors were just getting old and worn out.

She had been using Murphy Oil Soap for years and thought that the dullness was simply a sign of age.

But when I explained to her how Murphy Oil Soap can dull the finish, she was surprised.

We ended up refinishing her floors, and she was amazed at how much brighter and more vibrant they looked.

She switched to a different cleaning product and vowed never to use Murphy Oil Soap again.

If you’ve noticed that your hardwood floors are looking dull, it might be time to ditch the Murphy Oil Soap and try a different cleaning method.

You might be surprised at how much of a difference it makes.

Section 6: Warning #4 – Incompatibility with Certain Finishes

This is a big one, folks. Murphy Oil Soap isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution.

In fact, it can be downright harmful to certain types of hardwood floor finishes.

As I mentioned earlier, there are different types of finishes, and they all react differently to cleaning products.

Some finishes are more sensitive to water, while others are more susceptible to damage from oils or chemicals.

Murphy Oil Soap can be particularly problematic for floors with wax finishes or certain types of polyurethane finishes.

The oil in the soap can soften the wax, making it sticky and attracting even more dirt.

It can also react with certain polyurethane finishes, causing them to become cloudy or even peel off.

I’ve seen floors that were completely ruined by using Murphy Oil Soap on the wrong type of finish.

The finish was so damaged that the only solution was to completely refinish the floors.

And that’s an expensive and time-consuming process.

The bottom line is this: you need to know what type of finish you have on your floors before you use any cleaning product, including Murphy Oil Soap.

If you’re not sure, consult with a flooring professional or check with the manufacturer of your flooring.

It’s always better to err on the side of caution.

I once had a client who had beautiful, antique hardwood floors with a wax finish.

She had been using Murphy Oil Soap on them for years, thinking she was doing the right thing.

But when I came in to take a look, I could immediately see the damage.

The wax finish was soft, sticky, and covered in dirt.

It was a mess.

I had to carefully remove the old wax finish and apply a new one.

It was a delicate and time-consuming process, but in the end, her floors looked beautiful again.

But it could have been avoided if she had just known that Murphy Oil Soap was not compatible with her type of finish.

Section 7: Warning #5 – Difficulty in Refinishing

Okay, let’s say you’ve been using Murphy Oil Soap for years, and now you want to refinish your hardwood floors.

Think you can just sand them down and apply a new finish? Think again.

The residue from Murphy Oil Soap can actually make the refinishing process much more difficult and expensive.

The oil can penetrate deep into the wood, making it difficult for the new finish to adhere properly.

This can lead to problems like peeling, bubbling, or uneven coverage.

In some cases, the residue is so bad that the floors need to be professionally cleaned or even replaced before they can be refinished.

And that can add a significant amount of time and money to the project.

I’ve seen refinishing jobs that were supposed to take a few days turn into week-long ordeals because of Murphy Oil Soap residue.

The sanders get clogged, the finish doesn’t adhere properly, and the whole process becomes a nightmare.

One of the biggest challenges is that the residue can be invisible to the naked eye.

You might think you’ve cleaned the floors thoroughly, but the oil can still be lurking deep within the wood.

That’s why it’s so important to avoid using Murphy Oil Soap in the first place.

It’s simply not worth the risk of making refinishing more difficult down the road.

I remember one particularly challenging refinishing job where the homeowner had been using Murphy Oil Soap for over a decade.

The residue was so bad that we had to sand the floors down multiple times and use a special cleaning solution to remove the oil.

It added several days to the project and significantly increased the cost.

The homeowner was not happy.

But in the end, we were able to get the floors looking beautiful again.

But it was a hard-earned victory.

If you’re planning on refinishing your hardwood floors, be sure to let your flooring contractor know if you’ve been using Murphy Oil Soap.

They may need to take extra precautions to ensure that the new finish adheres properly.

Section 8: Warning #6 – Allergic Reactions and Sensitivities

While it’s marketed as a “natural” product, Murphy Oil Soap can still cause allergic reactions or sensitivities in some people.

The ingredients in the soap, including the fragrance, can trigger allergic reactions like skin rashes, itching, or respiratory problems.

People with sensitive skin or allergies to certain chemicals should be particularly cautious.

Even if you’ve never had an allergic reaction before, it’s always possible to develop one.

Allergies can develop at any time in your life.

I’ve heard from people who have used Murphy Oil Soap for years without any problems, and then suddenly develop an allergic reaction.

It’s not fun.

Symptoms of an allergic reaction to Murphy Oil Soap can include:

• Skin rashes or hives
• Itching or burning skin
• Redness or swelling
• Sneezing or coughing
• Watery eyes
• Difficulty breathing

If you experience any of these symptoms after using Murphy Oil Soap, stop using it immediately and consult with a doctor.

It’s also a good idea to do a patch test before using Murphy Oil Soap on a large area.

Apply a small amount of the soap to a discreet area of your skin and wait 24 hours to see if you develop any reaction.

If you have pets, be aware that they can also be sensitive to the ingredients in Murphy Oil Soap.

Keep them away from the area while you’re cleaning and make sure to rinse the floors thoroughly to remove any residue.

I once had a client whose dog developed a severe skin rash after she cleaned her floors with Murphy Oil Soap.

The dog was constantly scratching and biting at its skin, and it was clearly in a lot of discomfort.

She took the dog to the vet, who determined that the rash was caused by an allergic reaction to the Murphy Oil Soap.

She switched to a different cleaning product, and the dog’s rash cleared up within a few days.

It was a reminder that even “natural” products can be harmful to some people and animals.

Section 9: Warning #7 – False Sense of Security

Finally, let’s talk about the psychological aspect of using Murphy Oil Soap.

One of the biggest dangers is that it can give you a false sense of security.

You might think you’re doing a great job of maintaining your floors, but in reality, you’re actually causing more harm than good.

The “natural” label and the pleasant scent can lull you into a false sense of confidence.

You might be less likely to investigate alternative cleaning methods or to seek professional advice.

And that can lead to neglect of necessary maintenance practices, like refinishing or repairing damaged areas.

I’ve seen homeowners who have been using Murphy Oil Soap for years without ever realizing that they were damaging their floors.

They thought they were doing the right thing, but they were actually making the problem worse.

It’s like driving a car with a slow leak in the tire.

You might not notice it right away, but eventually, the tire will go flat.

And the longer you wait, the more damage will be done.

The same is true with Murphy Oil Soap.

The longer you use it, the more residue will build up, the more the finish will be dulled, and the more difficult it will be to refinish the floors.

It’s a slow and insidious process, but it can have a significant impact on the appearance and longevity of your hardwood floors.

Don’t let the false sense of security fool you.

Do your research, talk to a flooring professional, and choose a cleaning method that is safe and effective for your specific type of flooring.

Your floors will thank you for it.

Conclusion

So, there you have it: 7 pro warnings about using Murphy Oil Soap on hardwood floors.

From residue buildup to slippery surfaces to difficulty in refinishing, the potential risks are significant.

While Murphy Oil Soap may seem like a convenient and natural solution, the long-term consequences can be costly and frustrating.

I’m not saying that Murphy Oil Soap is always a bad choice.

But I am saying that you need to be aware of the potential risks and to consider alternative cleaning methods.

There are many other products on the market that are specifically designed for hardwood floors and that won’t leave behind a residue or damage the finish.

Do your research, read reviews, and talk to a flooring professional to find the best solution for your needs.

Sometimes, all you need is a damp microfiber mop and a little bit of elbow grease.

Your floors will thank you for it. And you’ll avoid the headaches and expenses associated with Murphy Oil Soap.

Learn more