No Underlayment? (3 Costly Mistakes!)

I’m a flooring contractor, and I’ve seen it all. From jaw-dropping transformations to DIY disasters.

I mean, literally!

Modern interior design is all about sleek lines, open spaces, and materials that just harmonize. Think clean, airy, and inviting.

Flooring is a HUGE part of that aesthetic. It sets the stage for the whole vibe.

But here’s a secret that many folks overlook: It’s not just about the visible flooring.

It’s also about what’s underneath. That unsung hero: the underlayment.

Now, I know what you might be thinking: “Underlayment? Sounds like an extra expense. Can I skip it?”

And that’s what I’m here to talk about. Because skipping underlayment can lead to some seriously costly mistakes.

Trust me, I’ve seen it happen. I’m going to break down the 3 biggest ones. So you can avoid them.

Mistake #1: Lack of Sound Insulation –

The Silent Killer of Home Tranquility

Ever walked into a home that just felt loud? Every footstep, every conversation echoing.

It is like living in a drum?

That’s often a sign of poor sound insulation. And guess what? Underlayment plays a major role in keeping things quiet.

Why is Sound Insulation Important?

In modern homes, especially with open-concept designs, sound travels everywhere.

Think about it: * Hardwood or laminate floors are gorgeous, but they’re not exactly sound-absorbing. * Open floor plans mean fewer walls to block noise. * Kids running around upstairs? You’ll hear everything downstairs.

Noise transmission between floors can really disrupt your peace and quiet. It can lead to stress, irritability, and a general feeling of unease.

I’ve had clients tell me they could hear every word of their neighbor’s conversations through the floor! Not exactly ideal, right?

How Underlayment Helps

Underlayment acts as a sound barrier, absorbing impact noise and reducing airborne sound.

Think of it like a sponge that soaks up the sound vibrations before they can travel through the floor.

Different types of flooring benefit from underlayment’s acoustic properties:

• Hardwood: Underlayment reduces the hollow sound of footsteps and prevents noise from traveling to lower floors.
• Laminate: Laminate flooring can be quite noisy without underlayment. It helps to dampen the sound and make it feel more solid.
• Vinyl: Even vinyl flooring can benefit from underlayment, especially in multi-story homes. It can improve sound absorption and make the floor feel softer underfoot.

Real-World Examples

I remember one client, Sarah, who had beautiful new hardwood floors installed in her upstairs bedrooms. She decided to skip the underlayment to save money.

Big mistake.

She quickly realized that every footstep, every creak, was amplified downstairs. Her husband, who worked from home, was constantly distracted by the noise.

“It was like living in a drum,” she told me. “I regretted not investing in underlayment from day one. It would have saved us so much stress.”

Another client, Mark, had laminate flooring installed in his basement. He also skipped the underlayment.

He soon discovered that the basement was incredibly echoey. Every sound bounced around the room, making it feel cold and unwelcoming.

He eventually had to tear up the laminate and install underlayment to fix the problem. A costly and time-consuming mistake!

The Science of Sound and Underlayment

Let’s get a little technical for a second.

Sound is measured in decibels (dB). The higher the dB level, the louder the sound.

Underlayment is rated by its Sound Transmission Class (STC) and Impact Insulation Class (IIC).

• STC: Measures how well the underlayment blocks airborne sound (e.g., voices, music). A higher STC rating means better sound insulation.
• IIC: Measures how well the underlayment blocks impact noise (e.g., footsteps, dropped objects). A higher IIC rating means better impact noise reduction.

According to the National Research Council of Canada, a minimum IIC rating of 50 is recommended for multi-family dwellings to provide adequate sound insulation.

And guess what? Most flooring materials alone don’t meet that standard. You need underlayment to bridge the gap.

The Cost of Silence

So, what’s the price of peace and quiet? Underlayment typically costs between $0.50 to $2.00 per square foot, depending on the type and quality.

Compared to the cost of tearing up your floors and re-installing them with underlayment, or the ongoing stress of living in a noisy home, it’s a relatively small investment.

My Recommendation

Don’t underestimate the importance of sound insulation in your home. It can make a huge difference in your quality of life.

Invest in quality underlayment that is specifically designed for sound reduction. Your ears (and your family) will thank you.

Mistake #2: Insufficient Moisture Barrier –

The Silent Destroyer of Floors

Moisture is the enemy of flooring. It can cause warping, mold growth, and premature deterioration.

And if you’re installing flooring in a basement, kitchen, or bathroom, moisture control is absolutely critical.

Why is Moisture Control Important?

Moisture can come from a variety of sources:

• Humidity: Especially in humid climates, moisture can seep into your floors from the air.
• Leaks: Plumbing leaks, roof leaks, or even minor spills can cause moisture damage.
• Concrete Slab: Concrete slabs can release moisture over time, even if they appear dry.
• Groundwater: In basements, groundwater can seep through the foundation walls and into the floor.

When moisture penetrates your flooring, it can lead to a host of problems:

• Warping: Wood flooring can warp and buckle when exposed to moisture.
• Mold Growth: Mold thrives in damp environments and can cause serious health problems.
• Deterioration: Moisture can break down the adhesive in your flooring, causing it to peel or crack.

I’ve seen countless cases where homeowners had to replace their entire floors due to moisture damage. It’s a heartbreaking and expensive experience.

How Underlayment Helps

Underlayment acts as a moisture barrier, protecting your flooring from water damage.

It prevents moisture from seeping up from the subfloor or down from spills and leaks.

Some types of underlayment even have a built-in moisture barrier, which provides an extra layer of protection.

Environments Where Moisture is a Major Concern

• Basements: Basements are notorious for moisture problems. They’re often below ground level and prone to groundwater seepage.
• Kitchens: Kitchens are high-traffic areas where spills are common. Moisture can also come from dishwashers, refrigerators, and sinks.
• Bathrooms: Bathrooms are exposed to high levels of humidity and water. Leaky toilets, showers, and sinks can all contribute to moisture damage.

Real-World Examples

I had a client, John, who installed laminate flooring in his basement without underlayment. He thought he was saving money, but he quickly regretted it.

A few months later, he noticed a musty smell in the basement. He pulled up a section of the laminate and discovered mold growing underneath.

The moisture had seeped up from the concrete slab and into the flooring. He had to tear up the entire basement floor and hire a mold remediation company.

“It was a nightmare,” he told me. “I ended up spending way more money than I would have if I had just installed underlayment in the first place.”

Another client, Lisa, had hardwood floors installed in her kitchen. She didn’t use underlayment because she thought the hardwood was waterproof.

She was wrong.

One day, her dishwasher leaked, and water seeped underneath the hardwood. The wood started to warp and buckle.

She had to replace a large section of her kitchen floor.

The Science of Moisture and Underlayment

Moisture vapor transmission (MVT) is the rate at which moisture passes through a material.

Underlayment is rated by its MVT, which is measured in pounds per 1,000 square feet per 24 hours.

A lower MVT rating means the underlayment is more effective at blocking moisture.

According to the Resilient Floor Covering Institute (RFCI), the maximum allowable MVT for most flooring materials is 3 pounds per 1,000 square feet per 24 hours.

If your subfloor has a higher MVT than that, you need to install underlayment with a low MVT rating to protect your flooring.

The Cost of Neglecting Moisture Barriers

The cost of repairing or replacing flooring due to moisture damage can be significant.

• Replacing Flooring: The cost of replacing flooring can range from $3 to $20 per square foot, depending on the material.
• Mold Remediation: Mold remediation can cost thousands of dollars, depending on the extent of the damage.
• Structural Repairs: In severe cases, moisture damage can lead to structural problems, which can be very expensive to repair.

My Recommendation

Don’t take chances with moisture control. It’s always better to be safe than sorry.

Install underlayment with a low MVT rating, especially in basements, kitchens, and bathrooms.

Consider using underlayment with a built-in moisture barrier for added protection.

Mistake #3: Increased Wear and Tear on Flooring –

The Hidden Cost of Premature Replacement

Flooring is an investment. You want it to last for years to come.

But without underlayment, your flooring is more susceptible to wear and tear. It can lead to scratches, dents, and premature degradation.

Why Does Flooring Wear Down Faster Without Underlayment?

Underlayment provides cushioning and support for your flooring. It helps to distribute weight evenly and absorb impact.

Without underlayment, your flooring is directly exposed to the subfloor. Every footstep, every piece of furniture, puts stress on the flooring material.

This can lead to a variety of problems:

• Scratches: Without underlayment, your flooring is more likely to get scratched by furniture, pets, and everyday wear and tear.
• Dents: Heavy objects can dent your flooring if there’s no underlayment to cushion the impact.
• Cracking: Over time, the stress of walking on your flooring can cause it to crack, especially in high-traffic areas.
• Loss of Shine: The surface of your flooring can become dull and worn down without the protection of underlayment.

Long-Term Financial Implications

Replacing flooring is expensive. The cost of materials and labor can quickly add up.

If you have to replace your flooring prematurely due to excessive wear and tear, you’re essentially throwing money away.

Underlayment can extend the lifespan of your flooring by several years, saving you money in the long run.

Expert Opinions and Statistics

According to the World Floor Covering Association (WFCA), underlayment can extend the life of your flooring by as much as 30%.

That means if your flooring is expected to last 10 years without underlayment, it could last 13 years with underlayment.

A study by the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) found that homeowners who installed underlayment with their flooring experienced fewer problems with wear and tear.

Real-World Examples

I had a client, David, who installed hardwood floors in his living room without underlayment. He loved the look of the wood, but he didn’t want to spend the extra money on underlayment.

Within a few years, the floors started to show signs of wear and tear. There were scratches and dents everywhere.

He eventually had to refinish the floors, which cost him a significant amount of money.

“I wish I had just installed underlayment in the first place,” he told me. “It would have saved me a lot of time and money.”

Another client, Susan, had laminate flooring installed in her hallway without underlayment. The hallway was a high-traffic area, and the flooring quickly started to wear down.

The surface of the laminate became dull and scratched. She had to replace the entire hallway floor after only a few years.

The Science of Wear and Tear

The Taber Abrasion Test is a common method for measuring the abrasion resistance of flooring materials.

In this test, a weighted wheel is rotated over the surface of the flooring, and the amount of material that is worn away is measured.

Flooring with a higher abrasion resistance rating is more durable and will last longer.

Underlayment can help to improve the abrasion resistance of your flooring by providing cushioning and support.

The Cost of Premature Replacement

The cost of replacing flooring can range from $3 to $20 per square foot, depending on the material.

If you have to replace your flooring every 5-7 years due to excessive wear and tear, you’ll end up spending a lot more money than if you had installed underlayment and extended the lifespan of your flooring.

My Recommendation

Protect your flooring investment by installing underlayment. It’s a small price to pay for the peace of mind knowing that your floors will last for years to come.

Choose underlayment that is specifically designed for your type of flooring and the amount of traffic it will receive.

Conclusion

So, there you have it. The 3 costly mistakes you can make by skipping underlayment.

• Lack of Sound Insulation: Disrupting your peace and quiet.
• Insufficient Moisture Barrier: Leading to warping, mold growth, and deterioration.
• Increased Wear and Tear: Causing premature degradation and costly replacement.

Underlayment is not just an optional expense. It’s a crucial component of any flooring project.

It protects your investment, enhances your comfort, and extends the life of your floors.

Don’t make the mistake of skipping it.

Invest in quality underlayment and enjoy the benefits of beautiful, functional, and long-lasting flooring.

Trust me, your floors (and your wallet) will thank you.

Learn more