Should Flooring Be Under Cabinets? (Explained)
When I first entered the flooring industry, I was often approached with questions that seemed straightforward at first glance. One question that always sparked a lively discussion was, “Should we put flooring under the cabinets?” This simple inquiry opened a floodgate of considerations, from aesthetics and functionality to future renovations and cost implications.
As I navigated numerous flooring projects, I found that this decision is rarely black and white. Each project brought unique challenges and opportunities for learning. In this conversation about flooring under cabinets, let’s uncover the complexities together.
The Tension Between Aesthetics and Practicality
The age-old debate about whether to install flooring under kitchen cabinets is a perfect example of how aesthetics can clash with practicality. While some homeowners may prioritize a seamless look throughout their space, others may lean toward budget-conscious decisions.
My Early Days: A Learning Experience
In my early days as a flooring contractor, I encountered a client who was in the midst of a kitchen remodel. They chose a beautiful dark hardwood for their floors but were hesitant about installing it under the cabinets. Their reasoning? “It’s going to be covered anyway, so why waste the money?”
This perspective is common among clients. However, I shared my experience: what if they decide to change their cabinets or countertops in a few years? Wouldn’t they prefer not to see a stark difference in flooring color? After some back-and-forth, we decided to install the hardwood underneath. I remember the look of relief on their faces when they realized they could easily change their kitchen layout in the future without worrying about mismatched flooring.
The Visual Impact
Imagine walking into a kitchen where the flooring abruptly stops beneath the cabinets. It can create an awkward visual break that disrupts the flow of the space. Many homeowners appreciate an uninterrupted look that makes their kitchen feel cohesive and complete. It’s a small detail that can have a big impact on the overall aesthetic.
The Argument for Future-Proofing
When discussing whether to install flooring under cabinets, future-proofing is a significant consideration. Homeowners often underestimate how much they may want to change their kitchens over time. I’ve had clients who initially planned to keep their cabinetry for years but ended up replacing them after just a few.
In one instance, I worked with a family who planned on keeping their oak cabinets for at least a decade. However, just three years later, they decided to remodel entirely. Because we had installed the hardwood flooring underneath, they didn’t have to worry about patching or matching floors when they replaced their cabinets.
The Cost Factor: Balancing Budget and Quality
Initial Costs vs. Long-Term Investment
One of the most significant factors influencing the decision is cost. Installing flooring under cabinets means purchasing extra materials and potentially increasing labor costs. However, these initial costs must be weighed against potential future expenses.
During one project, a client opted out of installing tile flooring under their cabinets to save money upfront. Unfortunately, they later dealt with water damage when their dishwasher leaked, costing them significantly more in repairs than if they had just invested in the extra tile initially.
Using FloorTally for Accurate Estimates
I rely heavily on tools like FloorTally for accurate cost estimates when discussing project budgets with clients. It breaks down material costs, labor rates, and helps me visualize how much we’ll need for different areas of the project.
For example, if I’m estimating costs for a kitchen that measures 300 square feet and using tile that costs $5 per square foot, the total would be $1,500. If we exclude 50 square feet under the cabinets, that’s a saving of $250. However, I always remind my clients to consider the long-term implications of that decision.
The Practical Side of Installation
Preparing for Installation
If you decide to install flooring under cabinets, proper preparation is crucial. Here are some steps I’ve learned over the years:
- Measure Carefully: Before installation, take precise measurements of the area where your cabinets will go. This ensures that you won’t waste material or be left with gaps.
- Choose the Right Flooring: Consider factors like moisture resistance and durability when selecting flooring materials. For instance, laminate or tile might work better in high-moisture areas like kitchens.
- Use Quality Underlayment: If using laminate or engineered wood, installing a moisture barrier or underlayment can protect against spills or leaks.
Considerations for Different Flooring Types
Different types of flooring come with unique characteristics and installation practices:
- Hardwood: A beautiful option that can expand and contract with temperature changes. It’s essential to acclimate hardwood before installation.
- Tile: Highly durable and moisture-resistant. It’s perfect for kitchens but requires precise installation methods.
- Laminate: Affordable and easy to install but requires careful attention to moisture levels.
Each type has its advantages and drawbacks, so it’s essential to choose based on your specific needs and future plans.
Maintenance: Keeping Your Floors Pristine
Once your flooring is installed under the cabinets, maintaining it is key to ensuring longevity:
- Regular Inspections: Check for any signs of wear or damage regularly. This is especially important in areas prone to spills.
- Clean Spills Promptly: If any liquid spills occur under the cabinets, clean them up immediately to avoid damage to your subfloor.
- Use Area Rugs: In high-traffic zones or near sinks, consider adding area rugs for protection against scratches or spills while allowing easy access to clean underneath.
Challenges and Lessons Learned
Throughout my career, I’ve faced many challenges related to this decision-making process. One project stands out clearly: I was tasked with remodeling an older home where the owner was adamant about not putting flooring under the cabinets due to budget constraints.
After finishing the kitchen remodel without laying floor beneath the cabinets, they had an unfortunate incident with a leaky sink. It resulted in extensive water damage that necessitated tearing out part of the subfloor to address repairs. The homeowner learned a hard lesson about cost-saving measures—sometimes what seems like savings can lead to higher expenses down the line.
Another challenge came during an installation where I used an unfamiliar brand of laminate flooring that claimed to be moisture-resistant. Unfortunately, it didn’t hold up as expected in high-humidity conditions. When discussing this with clients, I now emphasize choosing reputable brands and thoroughly researching materials before finalizing selections.
Comparative Analysis: Flooring Options
When deciding whether or not to install flooring under cabinets, it helps to compare different materials and approaches:
Hardwood vs. Tile vs. Laminate
Feature | Hardwood | Tile | Laminate |
---|---|---|---|
Aesthetic Appeal | Warmth and richness | Sleek and modern | Versatile designs |
Durability | Prone to scratches | Highly durable | Scratch-resistant |
Moisture Resistance | Moderate | Excellent | Moderate |
Cost | Higher initial investment | Moderate to high | Generally lower |
Ease of Installation | Moderate (professional recommended) | Requires expertise | DIY-friendly |
This table gives you a snapshot of how different options stack up against each other concerning key factors.
Final Thoughts on Flooring Under Cabinets
When considering whether or not to install flooring under cabinets, there isn’t one right answer for everyone. Each decision hinges on individual circumstances, including budgetary constraints, future renovation plans, and personal aesthetic preferences.
Think carefully about your long-term goals for your home. If you’re planning on staying put for several years and envision changing your kitchen someday, investing in flooring underneath your cabinetry can save you time and stress later on.
Conversely, if you’re looking at a tight budget and don’t foresee much change in your kitchen layout anytime soon, skipping that step may work for you.
In my experience as a contractor, every project teaches me something new about balancing client preferences with practical solutions. By sharing these stories and insights with you, I hope to help you make informed decisions about your own flooring projects.
Remember—no matter what choice you make regarding flooring under cabinets, ensuring quality installation and regular maintenance will go a long way toward keeping your home looking great for years to come!