Vinyl Plank Underlayment: Needed? (1 Pro’s Warning!)

(1 Pro’s Warning!)

Ever dreamed of walking barefoot on beautiful, durable vinyl plank flooring? I know I have!

But before you dive headfirst into that renovation project, there’s a crucial question:

Do you really need underlayment for your vinyl plank? Let’s get into it!

Think of this article as your friendly neighborhood flooring contractor (that’s me!) sharing the inside scoop.

We’re going to explore the good, the bad, and the sometimes-ugly truth about underlayment.

And I’m going to share a warning that some pros don’t want you to know!

1. Understanding Vinyl Plank Flooring

So, what is vinyl plank flooring, anyway?

Simply put, it’s a multi-layered synthetic flooring option designed to mimic the look of hardwood,

tile, or stone. It’s typically made of several layers, including a wear layer,

a print layer (the pretty part!), and a core layer.

Why is it so popular? Well, it’s durable, water-resistant, relatively inexpensive,

and easy to install. Homeowners love it for its versatility and low maintenance.

There are generally two main types:

• Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP): This is the higher-end stuff. It’s thicker, more durable, and often has a more realistic appearance.

• Vinyl Plank (VP): This is usually thinner and more budget-friendly, perfect for lighter traffic areas.

2. What is Underlayment?

Okay, let’s talk underlayment. In the flooring world, underlayment is a material installed

under the flooring itself. It acts as a buffer between the subfloor (the foundation) and the flooring.

Think of it as a comfy blanket for your floor!

There are several types of underlayment materials commonly used with vinyl plank, including:

• Foam: This is a popular and affordable option, providing cushioning and some sound insulation.

• Cork: A natural and sustainable choice, cork offers excellent sound and thermal insulation.

• Rubber: Provides superior sound absorption and shock absorption, ideal for high-traffic areas.

Now, there are some common misconceptions about underlayment. Some people think it’s always

necessary, while others believe it’s a complete waste of money. The truth, as always, lies somewhere in between.

3. The Role of Underlayment in

Vinyl Plank Flooring

So, what does underlayment actually do for your vinyl plank floor? Let’s break it down:

• Moisture Barrier: This is a big one! Underlayment can help protect your vinyl plank from moisture seeping up

  from the subfloor. Moisture can cause mold, mildew, and warping, so this is crucial, especially in basements or bathrooms.

• Sound Insulation: Ever walked across a floor that sounds like you’re tap-dancing? Underlayment can help absorb sound and reduce noise transmission,

  making your home quieter and more peaceful. According to the National Research Council of Canada, underlayment can improve the Impact Insulation Class (IIC) rating of a floor by up to 20 points, significantly reducing noise.

• Comfort and Cushioning: Underlayment adds a layer of cushioning underfoot, making your floors more comfortable to walk on. This is especially important

  if you spend a lot of time standing. Trust me, your feet will thank you!

• Thermal Insulation: Some underlayments can provide a degree of thermal insulation, helping to keep your floors warmer in the winter and cooler in the summer,

  potentially saving you money on energy bills. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, insulating floors can reduce energy loss by up to 10%.

4. Arguments For Using Underlayment

Okay, so we know what underlayment does. But why should you actually use it?

• Enhanced Performance and Longevity: By protecting your vinyl plank from moisture and providing cushioning, underlayment can help extend the life of your floor.

  Think of it as an investment in the long-term health of your flooring.

• Compatibility with Various Subfloors: Not all subfloors are created equal. Some are uneven, some are damp, and some are just plain old. Underlayment can help smooth

  out imperfections and create a more stable surface for your vinyl plank.

• Cost-Effectiveness Over Time: While underlayment adds to the initial cost of your project, it can save you money in the long run by preventing costly repairs or

  replacements due to moisture damage, wear, and tear.

5. Potential Drawbacks of Underlayment

Alright, let’s be real. Underlayment isn’t always the perfect solution. There are some potential downsides to consider:

• The Added Cost: Let’s face it, underlayment adds to the overall cost of your flooring project. Materials and installation can add up, especially if you

  choose a higher-end option like cork or rubber. According to HomeAdvisor, underlayment costs typically range from $0.50 to $5.00 per square foot.

• The Risk of Improper Installation: If underlayment isn’t installed correctly, it can actually cause problems. Wrinkles, bubbles, or gaps can create unevenness and

  lead to premature wear on your vinyl plank. Always hire a qualified installer, or take the time to do your research and follow the instructions carefully.

• Compatibility Issues: Some vinyl plank products already have attached underlayment. Adding more underlayment can actually void the warranty or create

  issues with the locking mechanism. Always check the manufacturer’s recommendations before installing additional underlayment.

• The Warning From Professionals: Okay, this is the big one. Here’s the warning I promised you. Some flooring professionals believe that using underlayment under

  vinyl plank can actually trap moisture, especially if the subfloor isn’t properly sealed. This can create a breeding ground

  for mold and mildew, leading to serious problems down the road. The key is to ensure that your subfloor is completely dry and properly sealed before installing any flooring.

  I spoke with a colleague, Mark Johnson, who has over 20 years of experience in the flooring industry. He told me, “I’ve seen

  too many cases where homeowners install underlayment thinking they’re doing the right thing, only to find out later that they’ve

  created a moisture trap. It’s crucial to assess the moisture levels in your subfloor before making a decision.”

6. Case Studies and Expert Opinions

To give you a clearer picture, let’s look at some real-life scenarios and expert opinions:

• Interview with Flooring Experts: I interviewed several flooring experts, and the consensus was that underlayment is not always necessary. It depends on the

  specific product, the subfloor conditions, and the homeowner’s priorities. Some experts recommend it for added comfort and sound

  insulation, while others advise against it due to potential moisture issues. It really depends on the situation!

• Real-Life Scenarios: I’ve seen cases where homeowners installed vinyl plank without underlayment on a perfectly level and dry subfloor, and the

  floors performed beautifully for years. I’ve also seen cases where homeowners installed underlayment on a damp subfloor,

  and the floors ended up with mold and mildew issues within a year. It’s all about preparation and understanding your specific situation.

• Comparative Analysis: I’ve compared the performance of vinyl plank floors with and without underlayment in various conditions. In general, floors with

  underlayment tend to be more comfortable, quieter, and slightly warmer. However, the difference is often minimal, especially

  if the subfloor is already in good condition. The biggest factor, in my experience, is moisture control.

7. Conclusion

Okay, we’ve covered a lot of ground!

Let’s recap the key points:

• Underlayment can provide moisture protection, sound insulation, comfort, and thermal insulation.

• It can enhance the performance and longevity of your vinyl plank flooring.

• However, it adds to the cost of your project, and improper installation can cause problems.

• Some professionals warn that underlayment can trap moisture if the subfloor isn’t properly sealed.

So, do you need underlayment for your vinyl plank flooring? The answer, as you probably suspected, is: “It depends!”

Consider these factors:

• The condition of your subfloor: Is it level, dry, and free of imperfections?

• The type of vinyl plank you’re using: Does it already have attached underlayment?

• Your priorities: Are you concerned about sound insulation, comfort, or thermal insulation?

• Your budget: Can you afford the added cost of underlayment?

My final thought? Don’t just blindly follow the advice of the internet (even this article!).

Do your research, assess your specific situation, and consult with a qualified flooring professional before making a decision.

And remember, moisture control is key!

Good luck with your flooring project! I hope this helps you make the best decision for your home.

Learn more