Nailing Hardwood: Spacing? (6 Nails to Ditch!)

Trust me, I’ve seen it all – the good, the bad, and the downright ugly.

It’s not just about banging nails into wood; it’s about understanding the wood itself, knowing how it breathes, and respecting its natural tendencies.

A properly installed hardwood floor is a thing of beauty, a testament to the skill and precision of the craftsman. But a poorly nailed floor? Well, that’s a recipe for squeaks, warps, and a whole lot of headaches down the road.

So, let’s dive into the nitty-gritty of nailing hardwood, and I’ll share some secrets I’ve learned over the years. We’ll talk spacing, techniques, and, most importantly, the “6 nails to ditch” that can make or break your project.

Section 1: Understanding Hardwood Flooring and Its Characteristics

Hardwood flooring is a classic choice for a reason. It’s durable, beautiful, and adds value to any home. But not all hardwood is created equal.

We’re talking oak, maple, cherry, walnut, hickory, and even exotic species like Brazilian cherry (Ipe). Each type has its own unique grain pattern, color, and hardness, which can impact how it reacts to nailing.

Here’s a quick rundown:

• Oak: A classic choice, known for its durability and readily available.
• Maple: Harder than oak, with a smoother grain.
• Cherry: Rich color that deepens over time.
• Walnut: Dark and luxurious, but softer than oak or maple.

The most important thing to remember about hardwood is that it’s a natural material. It expands and contracts with changes in humidity and temperature. This is why proper nailing techniques are so crucial.

If you nail the boards too tightly, you’re restricting their natural movement, which can lead to buckling, warping, and even cracking. On the other hand, if you don’t nail them securely enough, you’ll end up with a squeaky floor that drives you crazy.

According to the National Wood Flooring Association (NWFA), hardwood flooring should be installed at a moisture content that is consistent with the environment in which it will be used. This helps minimize expansion and contraction after installation.

Section 2: The Basics of Nailing Hardwood

Okay, let’s get down to the tools and techniques. Here’s what you need to know:

• Nails: Use flooring nails specifically designed for hardwood. These nails have barbs or rings that grip the wood fibers and prevent them from backing out. Cleat nails are also an option, especially for thinner boards.
• Nail Gun: A pneumatic nail gun is a lifesaver for larger projects. It drives nails quickly and consistently, saving you time and effort.
• Manual Nailing: For smaller jobs or repairs, a manual nailer and hammer will do the trick.

There are two main methods of nailing hardwood:

• Face Nailing: This is where you drive the nails directly through the surface of the board. It’s typically used for the first few rows along the walls, where you can’t use a nail gun.
• Blind Nailing: This involves driving the nails at an angle through the tongue of the board, so they’re hidden by the adjacent board. This is the preferred method for most of the floor.

The angle matters!

When blind nailing, aim for a 45-50 degree angle. This will ensure that the nail penetrates deep into the subfloor and provides a strong hold.

Proper nail placement is also crucial. Avoid nailing too close to the edge of the board, as this can cause splitting. And always make sure the nail is driven flush with the surface, without damaging the wood grain.

Section 3: Nail Spacing Explained

Now, let’s talk spacing. This is where things can get a little tricky. The general rule of thumb is to space nails 6-8 inches apart for solid hardwood flooring and 8-10 inches apart for engineered hardwood.

But there’s more to it than just following a set of numbers. You also need to consider the width of the boards, the type of wood, and the subfloor material.

Wider boards tend to expand and contract more than narrow boards, so they may require closer nail spacing. Harder woods, like maple or hickory, may also need closer spacing to prevent cupping or warping.

The subfloor also plays a role. If you’re nailing into a plywood subfloor, you can generally follow the standard spacing guidelines. But if you’re nailing into an older, less stable subfloor, you may need to reduce the spacing to provide extra support.

Here’s a table to give you a general idea:

Wood Type	Board Width (inches)	Nail Spacing (inches)
Solid Oak	2 1/4 – 3 1/4	6-8
Solid Maple	2 1/4 – 3 1/4	6
Engineered Oak	5	8-10
Engineered Hickory	5	8

Remember, these are just guidelines. Always consult the manufacturer’s recommendations for your specific flooring product.

Section 4: The Controversial 6 Nails to Ditch

Alright, this is where things get interesting. I’m about to challenge a practice that’s been ingrained in the flooring industry for years: over-nailing.

For years, the conventional wisdom has been that more nails are better. But I’m here to tell you that’s not always the case. In fact, I believe that reducing the number of nails can actually enhance the performance of your hardwood floor.

Why?

Because, as I mentioned earlier, hardwood needs to breathe. It needs to be able to expand and contract with changes in humidity. When you over-nail, you’re essentially trapping the wood and preventing it from moving naturally.

This can lead to a host of problems, including:

• Buckling: When the wood expands and has nowhere to go, it can buckle upwards, creating an uneven surface.
• Warping: Over-nailing can also cause the wood to warp, especially in areas with high humidity.
• Cracking: If the wood is too tightly fastened, it can crack under stress.

So, what are the “6 nails to ditch”? These are the extra nails that many installers add out of habit, without really considering the impact on the floor.

Here’s where I typically see over-nailing:

1. End Joints: Some installers like to add extra nails at the end joints of the boards. But if the subfloor is properly prepared and the boards are tightly butted together, these nails are usually unnecessary.
2. Near Walls: Along the walls, where you’re face-nailing, it’s easy to get carried away and add too many nails.
3. Random Spots: Sometimes, installers will add extra nails in random spots, just to “make sure” the floor is secure. But these nails can actually do more harm than good.

Here’s a story from my experience:

I once had a customer who insisted that I nail their hardwood floor every 4 inches. I tried to explain that it wasn’t necessary, but they wouldn’t budge. A few months later, they called me back complaining about buckling. Sure enough, the floor was over-nailed.

I had to remove some of the nails to allow the wood to move freely. After that, the buckling subsided, and the floor looked great.

Section 5: Best Practices for Nailing Hardwood

Okay, so how do you achieve the right balance between fasteners and wood movement? Here are some best practices I’ve learned over the years:

• Follow the Manufacturer’s Recommendations: This is always the first and most important step. The manufacturer knows their product best and will provide specific nailing guidelines.
• Use the Right Nails: Make sure you’re using flooring nails that are designed for hardwood. These nails have the right shank diameter and head shape to provide a secure hold without damaging the wood.
• Pre-Drill When Necessary: If you’re working with a particularly hard wood, or if you’re nailing close to the edge of the board, pre-drilling can help prevent splitting.
• Drive Nails Flush: It’s important to drive the nails flush with the surface of the wood, without damaging the grain. Use a nail set to countersink the nails slightly if necessary.
• Stagger End Joints: Staggering the end joints of the boards will create a stronger, more stable floor.
• Acclimate the Wood: Before you start nailing, make sure the hardwood has been acclimated to the environment in which it will be installed. This will help minimize expansion and contraction after installation.

Section 6: Troubleshooting Common Nailing Issues

Even with the best techniques, you may still encounter some common nailing issues. Here are a few problems I’ve seen and how to fix them:

• Squeaky Floors: Squeaks are often caused by loose nails or boards rubbing against each other. To fix this, try driving additional nails into the squeaky area. You can also use shims to fill any gaps between the subfloor and the hardwood.
• Warping: Warping is usually caused by excessive moisture or over-nailing. If the warping is minor, you may be able to flatten the boards by adding weight. If the warping is severe, you may need to replace the affected boards.
• Nail Pops: Nail pops occur when the nails back out of the wood. This can be caused by changes in humidity or improper nailing techniques. To fix nail pops, try driving the nails back in and then countersinking them slightly. You can also use wood filler to conceal the nail holes.
• Splitting: Splitting is caused by driving nails too close to the edge of the board or using nails that are too large. To prevent splitting, pre-drill holes before nailing and use nails that are the correct size for the wood.

Section 7: Conclusion: The Craft of Nailing Hardwood

So, there you have it – my take on the art of nailing hardwood. It’s a skill that takes time and practice to master, but it’s well worth the effort.

Remember, it’s not just about banging nails into wood. It’s about understanding the wood itself, respecting its natural tendencies, and taking pride in your work.

By ditching those unnecessary nails and following the best practices I’ve outlined, you can create a hardwood floor that is not only beautiful but also durable and long-lasting.

So, embrace the craft, take your time, and enjoy the process. And when you’re finished, stand back and admire your handiwork. You’ve created something that will be enjoyed for generations to come.

And that, my friends, is the true reward of being a flooring professional.

Learn more