Refinish or Replace Old Wood? (3 Factors!)

Choosing between refinishing and replacing old wood flooring is a HUGE decision.

It’s like deciding whether to give your trusty old car a fresh coat of paint and a tune-up, or trading it in for a brand-new model.

There’s a “best option” that balances looks, how much it costs, and how long it lasts.

This choice isn’t just about making your home look good right now.

It’s also about keeping up its value and making sure it’s easy to take care of for years to come.

I’m going to walk you through three critical factors that will help you make the right call.

Trust me, after reading this, you’ll be armed with the knowledge to make the best choice for your floors.

Ready? Let’s dive in!

Factor 1: Condition of the Wood

Okay, let’s get real.

The physical condition of your wood flooring is the first, and arguably most important, thing to consider.

Think of it like this: if your wood is riddled with problems, refinishing might be like putting lipstick on a pig – it might look better for a little while, but the underlying issues will still be there.

So, what should you be looking for?

• Scratches and Dents: Minor scratches and dents are usually no big deal.

  These can often be sanded out during the refinishing process.

  But, deep gouges or widespread damage?

  That’s a different story.

  I’ve seen floors where pet damage (ahem, those adorable but destructive puppies!) was so extensive that replacement was the only viable option.

• Warping: Warping is where the individual boards are no longer flat; they are bent upwards.

  This is a serious red flag.

  It’s usually caused by moisture, and it can be tough to fix without replacing the affected boards.

  Sometimes, severe warping can affect the entire floor, making replacement the only sensible choice.

• Water Damage: Water is wood’s worst enemy.

  Stains, discoloration, and even rot can occur.

  Small, isolated water stains might be manageable with refinishing.

  But, if you’re dealing with widespread water damage, especially near areas like bathrooms or kitchens, replacement is often the only long-term solution.

• Cupping and Crowning: Cupping is when the edges of the boards are higher than the center, creating a concave shape.

  Crowning is the opposite – the center is higher than the edges, creating a convex shape.

  Both are caused by moisture imbalances and can be difficult to correct without replacement.

Types of Wood and Durability

Not all wood floors are created equal.

The type of wood your floor is made of plays a HUGE role in determining whether refinishing is a viable option.

• Solid Hardwood: This is the gold standard.

  Solid hardwood can be sanded and refinished multiple times, making it a very durable and long-lasting choice.

  I’ve personally refinished solid oak floors that were over 100 years old and brought them back to their former glory.

• Engineered Hardwood: Engineered hardwood has a thin veneer of real wood on top of a plywood or high-density fiberboard (HDF) core.

  Whether you can refinish it depends on the thickness of that top veneer.

  Some engineered floors can be sanded and refinished once or twice, while others can’t be refinished at all.

  Always check with the manufacturer to see if your engineered floor can be refinished.

• Laminate Flooring: Laminate flooring is not real wood.

  It’s a photographic image of wood laminated onto a composite core.

  Laminate cannot be refinished.

  If your laminate floor is damaged, you’ll need to replace it.

Case Studies

Let’s look at a couple of real-world examples.

• Case Study 1: The Historic Home

  I worked on a historic home with solid oak floors that were covered in scratches and had some minor water stains.

  The homeowner was considering replacing them, but I advised them to try refinishing first.

  After sanding, staining, and applying a durable polyurethane finish, the floors looked amazing.

  We saved the homeowner a ton of money, and they got to preserve the original character of their home.

• Case Study 2: The Water-Damaged Kitchen

  I inspected a kitchen floor that had suffered a major water leak.

  The wood was warped and rotted in several areas.

  Refinishing was simply not an option.

  We had to replace the entire floor.

Professional Assessment vs. DIY

Okay, you might be tempted to assess the condition of your floors yourself.

And that’s fine for a basic assessment.

But, for a thorough evaluation, I highly recommend calling in a professional.

Here’s why:

• Experience: Professionals have seen it all.

  They know what to look for and can spot problems that you might miss.

• Tools: Professionals have the right tools to assess the condition of your floors, including moisture meters and specialized inspection equipment.

• Objectivity: It’s easy to be emotionally attached to your floors, especially if they’ve been in your home for a long time.

  A professional can provide an objective assessment of their condition.

DIY Evaluation

If you want to do a DIY evaluation, here are a few tips:

• Look closely: Get down on your hands and knees and examine your floors carefully.

  Pay attention to scratches, dents, warping, and water stains.

• Check for loose boards: Walk around your floors and listen for squeaks or creaks.

  Loose boards can indicate underlying problems.

• Test for moisture: If you suspect water damage, you can use a moisture meter to check the moisture content of the wood.

Alright, that’s a lot of information about the condition of your wood.

But trust me, understanding the state of your floors is the first crucial step in deciding whether to refinish or replace them.

Factor 2: Cost Analysis

Let’s talk money.

Cost is a major factor for most homeowners when deciding whether to refinish or replace old wood flooring.

It’s essential to understand the full financial picture before making a decision.

So, let’s break down the costs associated with both options.

Refinishing Costs

Refinishing typically involves sanding down the existing wood, applying a new stain (if desired), and then applying several coats of a protective finish, like polyurethane.

Here’s a breakdown of the costs:

• Materials: Sandpaper, stain (optional), polyurethane, brushes, rollers, etc.

  Expect to pay anywhere from $1 to $3 per square foot for materials.

• Labor: If you hire a professional, labor costs can range from $3 to $8 per square foot.

  This will vary depending on your location and the complexity of the job.

• Additional Costs: Don’t forget about additional costs like moving furniture, renting equipment (like a drum sander), and disposing of old materials.

  These can add up quickly.

Replacement Costs

Replacing your wood floors is a more significant investment.

Here’s what you can expect to pay:

• Materials: The cost of new wood flooring can vary widely depending on the type of wood you choose.

  Expect to pay anywhere from $5 to $15 or more per square foot for materials.

  Exotic hardwoods, like Brazilian cherry or tigerwood, will be more expensive than domestic hardwoods, like oak or maple.

• Labor: Installation costs can range from $3 to $10 per square foot, depending on the complexity of the job.

• Subfloor Repairs: If your subfloor is damaged or uneven, you’ll need to repair or replace it before installing the new flooring.

  This can add significantly to the overall cost.

• Additional Costs: Just like with refinishing, you’ll need to factor in the cost of moving furniture, disposing of old flooring, and any other unexpected expenses.

Long-Term Financial Implications

Don’t just think about the upfront costs.

Consider the long-term financial implications of your decision.

• Home Value: New hardwood floors can significantly increase the value of your home.

  According to the National Association of Realtors, new hardwood floors can provide a return on investment of up to 70-80% when you sell your home.

• Maintenance: Refinished or new hardwood floors are relatively easy to maintain.

  Regular sweeping and occasional mopping are usually all that’s needed.

  However, you’ll need to be careful to avoid scratching or damaging the finish.

Cost-Effectiveness

So, which is more cost-effective: refinishing or replacing?

It depends on the condition of your floors and your budget.

In general, if your floors are in relatively good condition, refinishing is the more cost-effective option.

You can save a significant amount of money by sanding down the existing wood and applying a new finish.

However, if your floors are severely damaged or you’re looking to upgrade to a different type of wood, replacement may be the better option.

Impact of Wood Type and Finishes

The type of wood and the finish you choose can also impact the overall costs and longevity of your floors.

• Wood Type: As I mentioned earlier, exotic hardwoods are more expensive than domestic hardwoods.

  But they’re also more durable and resistant to scratches and dents.

• Finishes: Different finishes have different levels of durability.

  Polyurethane is a popular choice because it’s durable and relatively inexpensive.

  But, other options, like oil-based finishes or water-based finishes, may offer better protection or a more natural look.

Table

Here’s a table summarizing the costs associated with refinishing and replacing wood floors:

Note: These are just estimates. Actual costs may vary depending on your location and the specific details of your project.

Factor 3: Aesthetic and Functional Goals

Alright, we’ve covered the condition of your wood and the costs involved.

Now, let’s talk about the fun stuff: aesthetics and functionality!

What do you want your floors to look like?

And how do you need them to perform?

These are critical questions to ask yourself when deciding whether to refinish or replace.

Trends in Flooring Styles

Flooring trends come and go, just like fashion trends.

What was popular 20 years ago might not be so desirable today.

• Color: Lighter wood tones, like blonde and gray, are currently very popular.

  These colors can make a room feel brighter and more spacious.

  Darker wood tones, like ebony and walnut, are still classic choices, but they can make a room feel smaller and more formal.

• Finish: Matte finishes are trending right now.

  They offer a more natural look and hide scratches and dents better than glossy finishes.

• Texture: Textured wood floors, like hand-scraped or wire-brushed floors, are also gaining popularity.

  These textures add character and visual interest to a room.

Functional Needs

The functional needs of different spaces can also dictate the best flooring option.

• High-Traffic Areas: In high-traffic areas, like hallways and living rooms, you’ll want a durable flooring option that can withstand a lot of wear and tear.

  Solid hardwood or engineered hardwood with a thick veneer are good choices.

• Low-Traffic Rooms: In low-traffic rooms, like bedrooms or home offices, you have more flexibility in your flooring choices.

  You might be able to get away with a less expensive option, like laminate or engineered hardwood with a thinner veneer.

• Bathrooms and Kitchens: Bathrooms and kitchens are prone to moisture, so you’ll want a water-resistant flooring option.

  Tile or vinyl are popular choices.

Testimonials and Insights

Let’s hear from some real people who have gone through the refinishing or replacement process.

• Sarah, Homeowner: “I refinished my hardwood floors last year, and I’m so glad I did! They look brand new, and it saved me a ton of money compared to replacing them.”

• John, Interior Designer: “When I’m working with clients, I always consider their lifestyle and aesthetic preferences when recommending flooring options. Sometimes refinishing is the best choice, and sometimes replacement is necessary to achieve the desired look.”

• Maria, Homeowner: “I replaced my old, worn-out carpet with new hardwood floors, and it completely transformed my living room. It’s so much easier to clean, and it looks so much more elegant.”

Technology and Modern Finishes

Modern technology has made refinishing and replacing wood floors easier and more durable than ever before.

• Dustless Sanding: Dustless sanding systems can significantly reduce the amount of dust generated during the sanding process.

  This makes refinishing a much cleaner and more convenient option.

• Durable Finishes: Modern finishes, like water-based polyurethane, are more durable and resistant to scratches and dents than ever before.

  They also come in a variety of sheens, from matte to glossy.

Conclusion

Alright, we’ve covered a LOT of ground!

We’ve talked about the condition of your wood, the costs involved, and your aesthetic and functional goals.

So, what’s the bottom line?

Should you refinish or replace your old wood floors?

The answer, as you probably guessed, is: it depends.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer.

The best option for you will depend on your unique circumstances.

But, by considering the three factors we’ve discussed, you’ll be well-equipped to make an informed decision.

So, what should you do next?

Take a close look at your floors.

Assess their condition.

Think about your budget.

Consider your aesthetic and functional needs.

And then, talk to a professional.

Get their expert opinion.

Ask them questions.

And then, make a decision that’s right for you.

Your floors are a big investment, so it’s important to get it right.

Good luck!

Learn more